# Q1 of 3

Principle: The legal defense of Volenti Non Fit Injuria (consent) applies when a person voluntarily agrees to suffer a known risk of harm. However, consent cannot be implied for harm arising from acts that exceed the customary or expected risks of the activity, such as negligence by the organizer.

Facts: Rohan purchased a front-row ticket to watch a professional motor racing Grand Prix. During the race, a racing car lost control due to defective brakes caused by negligent maintenance by the circuit mechanics. The car crashed through a substandard safety barrier that violated safety regulations, injuring Rohan. Rohan sues the race organizers for compensation. Decide.

Options
A.

The organizers are not liable because spectators voluntarily assume all risks by sitting in the front row.

B.

The organizers are liable because Rohan consented only to the ordinary risks of racing, not to harm caused by negligent maintenance and substandard safety barriers.

C.

The organizers are not liable because motor racing is inherently dangerous.

D.

Only the individual driver is liable, as organizers cannot foresee mechanical issues.

Show Answer
Correct Answer
B The organizers are liable because Rohan consented only to the ordinary risks of racing, not to harm caused by negligent maintenance and substandard safety barriers.
Solution

Correct Answer: The organizers are liable because Rohan consented only to the ordinary risks of racing, not to harm caused by negligent maintenance and substandard safety barriers.

Step-by-step Explanation:

  1. Understanding the Principle: Under Volenti Non Fit Injuria, consent applies only to inherent and customary risks of an activity. It does not shield a defendant against harm caused by their own negligence or failure to maintain mandatory safety standards.
  2. Application to Facts: A spectator at a motor race consents to normal racing risks (like flying gravel or engine noise), but does not consent to substandard safety barriers collapsing due to negligent maintenance.
  3. Therefore, the defense of volenti non fit injuria fails, and the organizers are liable.

Questions

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: