A student has an alternative conception that air contracts on heating. Which of the following strategies would you adopt to challenge this alternative conception?
Solution :
Correct Answer: Ask the students to attach a deflated balloon to the mouth of a bottle containing air and place the bottle in water bath containing boiling water and note down the observations.
Explanation:
When addressing alternative conceptions (misconceptions) in science, the most effective pedagogical strategy is providing a cognitive conflict through hands-on, experiential learning.
1. Understanding the Misconception:
The student believes that air contracts when heated. To challenge this belief effectively, students need direct, observable evidence that contradicts their initial idea.
2. Analyzing the Selected Activity:
When a deflated balloon is attached to the neck/mouth of a bottle filled with air and the bottle is placed in a hot water bath:
• Heat transfers from the boiling water to the air inside the bottle.
• As the air inside the bottle gets heated, its particles gain kinetic energy, move faster, and spread further apart, causing the air to expand.
• The expanding air moves into the balloon, causing the balloon to visibly inflate.
3. Why This Strategy Works:
By observing the balloon inflate upon heating, students directly witness that heating causes air to expand rather than contract. This visual and hands-on proof creates cognitive dissonance, encouraging them to update their mental model with the scientifically accurate concept.
Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.
Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.
Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.
Prepare effectively with the CTET Paper 2 Set E (20th August 2023) Question Paper with Solutions. This previous year paper includes fully solved questions with detailed explanations to help you understand the latest CTET exam pattern, improve conceptual clarity, and strengthen your preparation for Child Development & Pedagogy, Language I, Language II, Mathematics & Science, or Social Studies/Social Science. Practicing this authentic CTET previous year paper will help you analyze question trends, improve time management, and boost your confidence for upcoming CTET examinations. The official August 2023 Paper 2 Set E question paper is available through the CTET archive.
Prepare for the CTET Paper 2 Set M (31st January 2021) Question Paper with Solutions to strengthen your exam preparation with authentic previous year questions. This solved paper provides detailed explanations for every question, helping you understand the latest CTET syllabus, question pattern, and marking scheme. It covers Child Development & Pedagogy, Language I, Language II, Mathematics & Science, and Social Studies/Social Science, making it an excellent practice resource for aspiring upper primary teachers. Solving this previous year paper will improve your conceptual understanding, accuracy, and time management for the upcoming CTET examination.
Copyright © 2026 Combe Labs Private Limited. All Rights Reserved.