Question Details

Consider a demand paging system with three frames, and the following page reference string: 1 2 3 4 5 4 1 6 4 5 1 3 2. The contents of the frames are as follows initially and after each reference (from left to right):


The *-marked references cause page replacements.

Which one or more of the following could be the page replacement policy/policies in use?

Options

A

Least Recently Used page replacement policy

B

Least Frequently Used page replacement policy

C

Most Frequently Used page replacement policy

D

Optimal page replacement policy

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option D

Optimal page replacement policy

Solution :

The correct answer is: Optimal page replacement policy.

Detailed Step-by-Step Analysis:

The Optimal Page Replacement algorithm (also known as MIN or Belady's Optimal algorithm) replaces the page that will not be used for the longest period of time in the future.

Given:
- Number of frames = 3 (initially empty: [-,-,-])
- Page reference string: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 4, 1, 6, 4, 5, 1, 3, 2

Let us trace the frame contents step-by-step using the Optimal Page Replacement policy:

1. Reference 1 (Page Fault):
Frame 1 is empty, so page 1 is loaded.
Frames: [1,-,-]

2. Reference 2 (Page Fault):
Frame 2 is empty, so page 2 is loaded.
Frames: [1,2,-]

3. Reference 3 (Page Fault):
Frame 3 is empty, so page 3 is loaded.
Frames: [1,2,3] (This corresponds to column 3 in the image, where the bottom frame is filled with page 3).

4. Reference 4 (Page Fault with Replacement):
Page 4 is not in memory. We must replace one of the active pages in the frames: {1,2,3}.
Looking ahead at the future reference string: 5,4,1,6,4,5,1,3,2:
- Page 1 is referenced next at index 7.
- Page 2 is referenced next at index 13.
- Page 3 is referenced next at index 12.
Since page 2 is referenced furthest in the future, it is replaced by page 4.
Frames: [1,4,3] (This matches the column under header 5* in the image, where page 4 replaces page 2 in the second row).

5. Reference 5 (Page Fault with Replacement):
Page 5 is not in memory. We look ahead at the future reference string for {1,4,3}:
- Page 4 is referenced next (immediately at index 6).
- Page 1 is referenced next at index 7.
- Page 3 is referenced next at index 12.
Since page 3 is referenced furthest in the future, it is replaced by page 5.
Frames: [1,4,5]

6. Reference 4 & 1 (Page Hits):
Both pages are already in memory, so no replacements occur.
Frames remain: [1,4,5]

7. Reference 6 (Page Fault with Replacement):
Page 6 is not in memory. We look ahead at the future reference string for {1,4,5}:
- Page 4 is referenced next at index 9.
- Page 5 is referenced next at index 10.
- Page 1 is referenced next at index 11.
Since page 1 is referenced furthest in the future, it is replaced by page 6.
Frames: [6,4,5] (Matches the column under header 6* in the image, where page 6 replaces page 1 in the top row).

8. Reference 4 & 5 (Page Hits):
Both pages are in memory, so no replacements occur.
Frames remain: [6,4,5]

9. Reference 1 (Page Fault with Replacement):
Page 1 is not in memory. The remaining references are 3,2. None of the pages in memory {6,4,5} are referenced again. In case of ties, any page can be replaced. Following the trace in the image, page 4 is replaced by page 1.
Frames: [6,1,5] (Matches the column under header 1* in the image, where page 1 replaces page 4).

10. Reference 3 (Page Fault with Replacement):
Page 3 is not in memory. The remaining reference is 2. None of the pages in memory {6,1,5} are referenced again. Following the trace in the image, page 5 is replaced by page 3.
Frames: [6,1,3] (Matches the column under header 3* in the image).

11. Reference 2 (Page Fault with Replacement):
Page 2 is not in memory. No remaining references exist. Following the trace, page 6 is replaced by page 2.
Frames: [2,1,3] (Matches the final column under header 2* in the image).

Conclusion:
Since the state transitions of the frames and the positions of all page replacements (marked with asterisks *) perfectly match the execution of the Optimal page replacement strategy, the policy in use is the Optimal page replacement policy.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...