Consider the following Statements and Conclusions:
Statements:
1. Some rats are cats.
2. Some cats are dogs.
3. No dog is a cow.
Conclusions:
I. No cow is a cat.
II. No dog is a rat.
III. Some cats are rats.
Which of the above conclusions is/are drawn from the statements?
Correct Answer :
Only III
Solution :
The correct option is Only III.
To determine which of the conclusions logically follow from the given statements, we can analyze the relationships between the categories step-by-step:
Analysis of the Statements:
1. "Some rats are cats": This means there is an overlap (intersection) between the set of rats and the set of cats.
2. "Some cats are dogs": This means there is an overlap between the set of cats and the set of dogs.
3. "No dog is a cow": This means that the set of dogs and the set of cows have absolutely no overlap; they are completely disjoint.
Evaluating the Conclusions:
Conclusion I: "No cow is a cat"
While we know that no dog is a cow, and some cats are dogs, there is no restriction preventing cows from overlapping with the portion of cats that are not dogs. Because an overlap between cows and cats is possible, we cannot definitively conclude that "No cow is a cat". Therefore, Conclusion I does not follow.
Conclusion II: "No dog is a rat"
We are given that some rats are cats and some cats are dogs. There is no direct or indirect relation established between rats and dogs. Since they may or may not overlap, we cannot definitely conclude that "No dog is a rat". Therefore, Conclusion II does not follow.
Conclusion III: "Some cats are rats"
Statement 1 directly tells us that "Some rats are cats". In syllogisms, the converse of a "some" statement is always true (i.e., if some A are B, then some B are A). Therefore, the conclusion "Some cats are rats" directly and logically follows from Statement 1. Thus, Conclusion III follows.
Consequently, only Conclusion III can be logically drawn from the statements.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Mindyard. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Mindyard. All Rights Reserved.