Question Details

Consider the standard second-order system of the form  ω n 2 s 2 + 2 ζ ω n s + ω n 2  with the poles p and p having negative real parts. The pole locations are also shown in the figure. Now consider two such second-order systems as defined below:

System 1 :  ω n = 3 rad / sec and  θ = 60

System 2 :  ω n = 1 rad / sec and  θ = 70

Options

A

Settling time of system 1 is more than that of system 2.

B

Settling time of system 2 is more than that of system 1.

C

Settling times of both the systems are the same.

D

Settling time cannot be computed from the given information.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option B

Settling time of system 2 is more than that of system 1.

Solution :

The correct option is: Settling time of system 2 is more than that of system 1.

1. Analysis of the Pole Locations in the s-Plane:
From the provided image, we can observe the following elements in the s-plane diagram:
- The horizontal real axis is labeled as σ.
- The vertical imaginary axis is labeled as jω.
- A pole is plotted at location p in the second quadrant, with its complex conjugate pole at p in the third quadrant. Both lie on a dashed circular arc representing a constant natural frequency ωn.
- The angle θ is measured between the negative real axis and the radial line from the origin to the pole p.

For a standard second-order system, the poles are represented as:

p,p=-ζωn±jωn1-ζ2

Using basic trigonometry on the right-angled triangle formed by the origin, the pole p, and the real axis, we find the relation between the damping ratio ζ and the angle θ:

cos(θ)=ζωnωn=ζ

Thus, the damping ratio is given by ζ=cos(θ).

2. Settling Time Formula:
The settling time Ts for a second-order system is determined by the real part of its poles, which is ζωn. Using the 2% settling time criterion, we have:

Ts=4ζωn

This shows that settling time is inversely proportional to the product ζωn.

3. Calculations for Each System:
Let us calculate the value of ζωn for both systems:

System 1:
- Given: ωn=3 rad/sec and θ=60
- Damping ratio: ζ1=cos(60)=0.5
- Real part value:

ζ1ωn1=0.5×3=1.5 rad/sec

System 2:
- Given: ωn=1 rad/sec and θ=70
- Damping ratio: ζ2=cos(70)0.342
- Real part value:

ζ2ωn2=0.342×1=0.342 rad/sec

4. Comparison and Conclusion:
Comparing the real pole coordinates of both systems:

ζ1ωn1=1.5>ζ2ωn2=0.342

Since System 2 has a smaller real part (ζωn) than System 1, its poles are closer to the imaginary axis. Consequently, its response decays more slowly, yielding a larger settling time:

Ts2>Ts1

Thus, the settling time of system 2 is more than that of system 1.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...