Question Details

Consider two cases as below.

Case 1: A company buys 1000 pieces per year of a certain part from vendor 'X'. The changeover time is 2 hours and the price is Rs. 10 per piece. The holding cost rate per part is 10% per year.

Case 2: For the same part, another vendor 'Y" offers a design where the changeover time is 6 minutes, with a price of Rs. 5 per piece, and a holding cost rate per part of 100% per year. The order size is 800 pieces per year from 'X' and 200 pieces per year from 'Y’.

Assume the cost of downtime as Rs. 200 per hour. The percentage reduction in the annual cost for Case 2, as compared to Case 1 is___________ (round off to 2 decimal places).

Show Answer
Correct Answer

Correct answer is : 5.32

Given, for case (i)

Q = 1000, C = Rs. 10, r = 10% and Cost of downtime = 200/hr, Change over time = 2 hrs

Then,

T c 1 = 1000 × 10 + 1000 2 × 10 × 10 100 + 200 × 2 = R s . 10900

Case (ii)

800 units are ordered from vendor X then total cost from vendor X, only the units will change other conditions will remain the same as the vendor is the same

T c x = 800 × 10 + 800 2 × 10 × 10 100 + 200 × 2 = R s . 8800

For vendor Y

Q = 200, C = Rs. 5, r = 100% and Cost of downtime = 200/hr, Change over time = 6 minutes

T c y = 200 × 5 + 200 2 × 5 × 100 100 + 200 × 1 10 = R s . 1520

Therefore  T c 2 = 8800 + 1520 = R s . 10320

Now the percentage reduction in cost in case (ii)

% r e d u c t i o n = T c 1 − T c 2 T c 1 × 100 = 10900 − 10320 10900 × 100 = 5.321 %

Since %reduction in EOQ model is more compared to the single order therefore the correct answer will be 8.209%.

Solution :

The correct answer is 5.32.

To find the percentage reduction in the annual cost for Case 2 compared to Case 1, we need to calculate the total annual cost for both scenarios. The total annual cost is composed of three components:
1. Purchase Cost: Calculated as the order size multiplied by the price per piece.
2. Holding Cost: Calculated as the average inventory level multiplied by the holding cost rate per part.
3. Downtime (Changeover) Cost: Calculated as the cost of downtime per hour multiplied by the changeover time in hours.

Let's define the general formula for the total cost:
Tc = (Q×C) + Q2×C×r + (Downtime Cost/hour×Changeover Time)
where:
- Q is the annual order size (pieces per year).
- C is the cost price per piece.
- r is the holding cost rate per year.

Step 1: Calculate the Total Annual Cost for Case 1 (Tc1)
For Case 1, the company buys 1000 pieces per year from vendor X. The parameters are:
- Q=1000 pieces per year
- C=Rs. 10 per piece
- r=10%=0.10
- Changeover time = 2 hours
- Downtime cost = Rs. 200 per hour
Substituting these values into our cost formula:
Tc1 = 1000×10 + 10002×10×0.10 + 200×2
Tc1 = 10000+500+400 = Rs. 10900

Step 2: Calculate the Total Annual Cost for Case 2 (Tc2)
In Case 2, the order size is split between vendor X (800 pieces per year) and vendor Y (200 pieces per year). We calculate the individual costs for each vendor and then sum them up.

Cost from Vendor X (Tcx)
Only the quantity changes to 800; other vendor X specific parameters remain the same:
- Q=800 pieces per year
- C=Rs. 10 per piece
- r=10%=0.10
- Changeover time = 2 hours
Tcx = 800×10 + 8002×10×0.10 + 200×2
Tcx = 8000+400+400 = Rs. 8800

Cost from Vendor Y (Tcy)
The parameters for vendor Y are:
- Q=200 pieces per year
- C=Rs. 5 per piece
- r=100%=1.0
- Changeover time = 6 minutes = 660=0.1 hour
Tcy = 200×5 + 2002×5×1.0 + 200×0.1
Tcy = 1000+500+20 = Rs. 1520

Total Cost for Case 2 (Tc2)
Summing the costs of X and Y:
Tc2 = Tcx + Tcy = 8800+1520 = Rs. 10320

Step 3: Calculate the Percentage Reduction
The percentage reduction in the annual cost from Case 1 to Case 2 is calculated as:
% Reduction = Tc1-Tc2Tc1 × 100
Substituting the total costs:
% Reduction = 10900-1032010900 × 100
% Reduction = 58010900 × 100 ≈ 5.3211%
Rounding off to two decimal places gives a percentage reduction of 5.32%.

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • GATE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • mechanical engineering

The GATE 2026 Mechanical Engineering (ME) examination scheduled for 14 February 2026 is one of the most important national-level competitive exams for engineering graduates aspiring for higher education and prestigious career opportunities in PSU and research organizations. Conducted annually at the national level, the GATE Mechanical Engineering paper evaluates candidates on core subjects such as Engineering Mechanics, Thermodynamics, Fluid Mechanics, Strength of Materials, Manufacturing Processes, and Machine Design, along with General Aptitude and Engineering Mathematics. This examination is a gateway for admission into M.Tech/Ph.D. programs at IITs, NITs, IISc, and other top institutions, as well as recruitment in major Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs) like ONGC, NTPC, BHEL, IOCL, and more. The GATE ME 2026 paper will test conceptual understanding, analytical thinking, and problem-solving ability, making strong preparation essential for success. Candidates are advised to practice previous year papers, mock tests, and focus on conceptual clarity for high scoring performance. This exam on 14/02/2026 is a crucial opportunity for mechanical engineering aspirants to secure their future in academia and industry.

  • GATE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • mechanical engineering

Strengthen your preparation with this GATE 2025 Mechanical Engineering (ME) test, covering core subjects such as thermodynamics, fluid mechanics, strength of materials, theory of machines, and manufacturing engineering. With a well-balanced mix of conceptual and numerical questions, this test helps enhance problem-solving ability and technical understanding. Aligned with the latest exam pattern, it is ideal for improving accuracy, speed, and overall exam readiness.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: