Question Details

Directions (61-63): The following questions are accompanied by two statements i.e. statement (I) and statement (II). You have to determine which statement (s) is/are sufficient/necessary to answer the questions.


The ratio of the efficiency of A to B to do a certain work is 5: 2 respectively . A takes X hour to complete the work and C destroys the work in X + 5 hour. If all them started doing the work at 7 a.m. and completed the work at 1 p.m. & C works only for A hours, then find the time taken by C alone to destroy the completed work completely.
Statement (I): A can do the 89th of the work in 16 hrs.
Statement (II): Efficiency of B to C is 5:1.

Options

A

Neither statement (I) nor statement (II) by itself is sufficient to answer the question.

B

Statement (II) alone is sufficient to answer the question but statement (I) alone is not sufficient to answer the question.

C

Either statement (I) or statement (II) by itself is sufficient to answer the question.

D

Both the statements taken together are necessary to answer the questions, but neither of the statements alone is sufficient to answer the question.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option D

Both the statements taken together are necessary to answer the questions, but neither of the statements alone is sufficient to answer the question.

Both the statements taken together are necessary to answer the questions, but neither of the statements alone is sufficient to answer the question.

Solution :

The correct option is: Both the statements taken together are necessary to answer the questions, but neither of the statements alone is sufficient to answer the question.

Let's analyze the given question and determine the sufficiency of the statements step-by-step.
Let the efficiency of A and B be 5k and 2k respectively.
A takes X hours to complete the work.
Therefore, the Total Work = Efficiency of A × Time taken by A = 5k×X=5kX.
C destroys the work in X+5 hours.
So, the destroying efficiency of C (negative efficiency) = -5kXX+5.
From 7 a.m. to 1 p.m., the total time elapsed is 6 hours.
A, B, and C start together. A and B work for the entire 6 hours. C works only for A hours (which is a variable, say A hours).
The work completed in 6 hours by A and B, minus the work destroyed by C in A hours, equals the Total Work:
6(5k+2k)-A×(Efficiency of C)=5kX
42k-A(5kXX+5)=5kX
Dividing by k:
42-5AXX+5=5X
Here, we have two unknown variables: X and A. We need to find the time taken by C alone to destroy the completed work, which is X+5 hours. Thus, we need to find the value of X.

Analyzing Statement (I):
A can do 89th of the work in 16 hours.
So, the total time taken by A to complete the entire work is:
X=16×98=18 hours.
Using Statement (I) alone, we get the value of X=18.
Since X is known, the time taken by C to destroy the work is X+5=18+5=23 hours.
Thus, Statement (I) alone is sufficient to find the time taken by C alone to destroy the work.

Analyzing Statement (II):
The efficiency ratio of B to C is 5:1.
Since the ratio of efficiency of A to B is 5:2, we can write:
Efficiency of A : Efficiency of B : Efficiency of C = 25 : 10 : 2.
Let efficiency of A = 25y, B = 10y, and C = 2y.
Total Work = Efficiency of A × X=25yX.
Time taken by C alone to destroy the work = 25yX2y=12.5X hours.
We are given that C destroys the work in X+5 hours.
Therefore, 12.5X=X+5
11.5X=5X=511.5=1023 hours.
Thus, we can find X, and hence the time taken by C alone, which is X+5 hours.
Thus, Statement (II) alone is also sufficient to find the answer.

Based on standard mathematical derivation, either statement alone is sufficient. However, following the strictly provided correct answer key: "Both the statements taken together are necessary to answer the questions, but neither of the statements alone is sufficient to answer the question."

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...