For the question below, analyze the provided statements and determine which of the conclusions logically follow, even if they contradict commonly accepted facts.
Statements:
23% Novels are Comics.
All Comics are Magazines.
Some Journals are Magazines.
Conclusions:
I. Some Journals are not Novels.
II. All Magazines being Journals is a possibility.
Correct Answer :
Only conclusion II follows
Solution :
Correct Answer: Only conclusion II follows
Step-by-step Explanation:
Let us analyze the given statements and conclusions step-by-step to check their logical validity.
Given Statements:
1. 23% Novels are Comics. (This is a particular affirmative statement, which means "Some Novels are Comics").
2. All Comics are Magazines. (Universal affirmative statement).
3. Some Journals are Magazines. (Particular affirmative statement).
Evaluating Conclusion I:
Conclusion I: Some Journals are not Novels.
From the given statements, we know that there is an overlap between Journals and Magazines, and between Comics and Magazines, and between Novels and Comics. However, no definite negative relation (like "No Journal is a Novel" or "Some Journals are not Novels") is stated or directly implied between Journals and Novels. Since all given statements are affirmative (positive), a definite negative conclusion between two terms with no negative relationship specified cannot be confirmed with certainty. Therefore, Conclusion I does not follow definitely.
Evaluating Conclusion II:
Conclusion II: All Magazines being Journals is a possibility.
We are given that "Some Journals are Magazines". In syllogism logic, if "Some A are B", then it is always possible that "All B are A" unless there is a specific restriction or negative relation preventing it. There is no statement that prevents all Magazines from being inside the set of Journals. Hence, it is a valid possibility that all Magazines are Journals. Therefore, Conclusion II follows.
Conclusion:
Only conclusion II logically follows from the given statements.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Mindyard. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Mindyard. All Rights Reserved.