Question Details

Gradually Varied Flow (GVF) profiles in open channels given in Column 1 are to be matched with the water surface slopes in Column 2 in the table below.


Column 1 GVF Profile Column 2 Water Surface Slope (P) M1 (I) Positive (Q) M2 (II) Negative (R) M3 (III) Zero


Which of the following options is/are NOT correct?

Options

A

(P)- (I) ; (Q)- (II) ; (R)- (I)

B

(P)- (I) ; (Q)- (II) ; (R)- (III)

C

(P)- (II) ; (Q)- (I) ; (R)- (I)

D

(P)- (I) ; (Q)- (III) ; (R)- (II)

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option B

(P)- (I) ; (Q)- (II) ; (R)- (III)

Option C

(P)- (II) ; (Q)- (I) ; (R)- (I)

Option D

(P)- (I) ; (Q)- (III) ; (R)- (II)

Solution :

The correct options that are NOT correct are:
1. (P)- (I) ; (Q)- (II) ; (R)- (III)
2. (P)- (II) ; (Q)- (I) ; (R)- (I)
3. (P)- (I) ; (Q)- (III) ; (R)- (II)

Step-by-Step Explanation:

To determine which options are incorrect, we first need to find the correct relationship between the Gradually Varied Flow (GVF) profiles and their corresponding water surface slopes (dy/dx).

The dynamic equation for Gradually Varied Flow in an open channel is given by:

d y d x = S 0 1 - ( y n y ) N 1 - ( y c y ) M

where:
- y is the depth of flow at any section.
- yn is the normal depth of flow.
- yc is the critical depth of flow.
- S0 is the longitudinal bed slope (positive for mild slope channels).
- dy/dx is the water surface slope relative to the channel bed.
- N and M are positive exponents.

For a mild slope (M), the normal depth is greater than the critical depth:

y n > y c

Now, let us analyze each of the three zones for a mild slope:

1. M1 Profile (Zone 1):
This zone lies above both the normal depth line and the critical depth line, where:

y > y n > y c

Since y > yn, we have:

1 - ( y n y ) N > 0

Since y > yc, we have:

1 - ( y c y ) M > 0

Since both the numerator and the denominator are positive, the slope dy/dx is positive:

d y d x > 0

Therefore, (P) matches with (I) Positive.

2. M2 Profile (Zone 2):
This zone lies between the normal depth line and the critical depth line, where:

y n > y > y c

Since y < yn, we have:

1 - ( y n y ) N < 0

Since y > yc, we have:

1 - ( y c y ) M > 0

Thus, the numerator is negative and the denominator is positive, meaning the slope dy/dx is negative:

d y d x < 0

Therefore, (Q) matches with (II) Negative.

3. M3 Profile (Zone 3):
This zone lies below both the normal depth line and the critical depth line, where:

y n > y c > y

Since y < yn, we have:

1 - ( y n y ) N < 0

Since y < yc, we have:

1 - ( y c y ) M < 0

Since both the numerator and the denominator are negative, the ratio becomes positive, meaning the slope dy/dx is positive:

d y d x > 0

Therefore, (R) matches with (I) Positive.

Conclusion:
The correct matching sequence is:
(P)- (I) ; (Q)- (II) ; (R)- (I)

Since the question asks for the options that are NOT correct, any option other than the correct match is correct as a choice for the question. Thus, the three incorrect options are:
- (P)- (I) ; (Q)- (II) ; (R)- (III)
- (P)- (II) ; (Q)- (I) ; (R)- (I)
- (P)- (I) ; (Q)- (III) ; (R)- (II)

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • GATE
  • beginner
  • 3 hours
  • civil engineering

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...