Question Details

If four distinct positive numbers, a, b, c and d, in the order given are in proportion, then which of the following options is NOT correct?

Options

A

b, a, d and c, in the order given are in proportion.

B

c, d, b and a, in the order given are in proportion.

C

a, c, b and d, in the order given are in proportion.

D

d, c, b and a, in the order given are in proportion.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option B

c, d, b and a, in the order given are in proportion.

Solution :

The correct answer is: "c, d, b and a, in the order given are in proportion." — this statement is NOT correct.

Understanding the starting condition:

We are told that four distinct positive numbers a, b, c, d (in that order) are in proportion. This means:

ab=cd

This is the fundamental relationship, and it also implies (by cross-multiplication):

a×d=b×c

We will use these two facts to check each option.


Option 1: b, a, d, c — Is this in proportion?

Check if ba=dc

Starting from ab=cd, we can take the reciprocal of both sides:

ba=dc

This is TRUE — it is a valid proportion (invertendo property).


Option 2: c, d, b, a — Is this in proportion?

Check if cd=ba

We know from the original condition that cd=ab

So the question becomes: is ab=ba ?

This would require a2=b2, i.e., a = b. But the problem states all four numbers are distinct. Therefore, this equality does NOT hold in general.

This statement is NOT CORRECT. ✗


Option 3: a, c, b, d — Is this in proportion?

Check if ac=bd

Cross-multiplying: a×d=b×c

This is exactly the cross-product we derived from the original proportion! ✓

This is TRUE — it is a valid proportion (alternendo property).


Option 4: d, c, b, a — Is this in proportion?

Check if dc=ba

From Option 1, we already proved ba=dc

This is the same relation, just written in reverse order. ✓

This is TRUE — it is a valid proportion (inverse alternendo property).


Conclusion:
The only option that is NOT a valid proportion is Option 2: c, d, b and a. Claiming cd=ba would contradict the fact that a, b, c, d are all distinct, because it would force a = b.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CTET
  • intermediate
  • No time limit
  • child development and pedagogy, mathematics, social science

  • SSC
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours and 30 mins
  • child development and pedagogy, mathematics, social science

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...