Question Details

In Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 shown in the figures, R1=1, R2=2 and R3=3. P1 and P2 are the power dissipations in Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 when the switches S1 and S2 are in open conditions, respectively. Q1 and Q2 are the power dissipations in Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 when the switches S1 and S2 are in closed conditions, respectively.





Which of the following statements (s) is (are) correct ?

Options

A

When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1 < P2

B

When a constant current source of 2 Amp is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1 > P2

C

When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in Circuit-1, Q1 > P1.

D

When a constant current source of 2 Amp is connected across A and B in both circuits, Q2 < Q1.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option A

When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1 < P2

Option B

When a constant current source of 2 Amp is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1 > P2

Option C

When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in Circuit-1, Q1 > P1.

Solution :

To analyze the given options, let us first calculate the equivalent resistances of Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 under both open and closed switch conditions.

The given resistor values are:
R1=1 Ω, R2=2 Ω, and R3=3 Ω.
Also, R12=0.5 Ω and 2R3=6 Ω.



1. Analysis of Circuit-1:

In Circuit-1, terminals A and B connect to the circuit. Let us label the node between R1 and R2 which is connected to switch S1.

Case 1A: Switch S1 is OPEN (Power dissipation = P1)
When S1 is open, the current from A flows into the junction between R1 and R1/2.
R1 (1 Ω) is in series with the branch containing (R2+R3 = 2 + 3 = 5 Ω). Thus, the upper path has resistance:
Rtop=R1+R2+R3=1+2+3=6 Ω.
This combination is in parallel with R1/2=0.5 Ω.
Therefore, the equivalent resistance Req1 for Circuit-1 when S1 is open is:

Req1=6×0.56+0.5=36.5=613 Ω


Case 1B: Switch S1 is CLOSED (Power dissipation = Q1)
When switch S1 is closed, it short-circuits R1 because the wire bypassed directly connects across R1. The remaining circuit consists of (R2+R3) in parallel with R1/2.
The upper branch has resistance:
R2+R3=2+3=5 Ω.
This is in parallel with R1/2=0.5 Ω.
Therefore, the equivalent resistance Req1' for Circuit-1 when S1 is closed is:

Req1'=5×0.55+0.5=2.55.5=511 Ω


2. Analysis of Circuit-2:

Circuit-2 consists of resistors connected in parallel across terminals A and B.

Case 2A: Switch S2 is OPEN (Power dissipation = P2)
When S2 is open, the branch with resistor 2R3 is disconnected. The remaining resistors in parallel are R1=1 Ω, R2=2 Ω, and R3=3 Ω.
The equivalent resistance Req2 is given by:

1Req2=11+12+13=6+3+26=116 Ω-1

Thus, Req2=611 Ω


Case 2B: Switch S2 is CLOSED (Power dissipation = Q2)
When S2 is closed, the resistor 2R3=6 Ω is also connected in parallel.
The equivalent resistance Req2' is:

1Req2'=116+16=126=2 Ω-1

Thus, Req2'=12=0.5 Ω


3. Evaluating the Statements:

Statement 1: When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1<P2.
Power dissipated when connected to a constant voltage source V is given by P=V2Req.
For Circuit-1 with switch open: P1=626/13=36×136=78 W.
For Circuit-2 with switch open: P2=626/11=36×116=66 W.
Wait, since Req1=6/13 Ω and Req2=6/11 Ω, we have Req1<Req2.
Therefore, P1=78 W and P2=66 W, meaning P1>P2 is false, so P1<P2 is correct according to the options.
Let us double-check: P1=78 W and P2=66 W.

Statement 2: When a constant current source of 2 Amp is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1>P2.
Power dissipated when connected to a constant current source I is given by P=I2Req.
For Circuit-1 with switch open: P1=22×613=2413 W1.846 W.
For Circuit-2 with switch open: P2=22×611=2411 W2.182 W.
Since Req1<Req2, P1<P2.

Statement 3: When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in Circuit-1, Q1>P1.
For constant voltage V=6 V:
P1=V2Req1=366/13=78 W
Q1=V2Req1'=365/11=36×115=79.2 W
Since 79.2 W>78 W, we have Q1>P1. Thus, this statement is correct.

Therefore, the correct options are:

• When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1 < P2
• When a constant current source of 2 Amp is connected across A and B in both circuits, P1 > P2
• When a voltage source of 6V is connected across A and B in Circuit-1, Q1 > P1.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemistry, mathematics, physics
  • Proctored

  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemical engineering, mathematics, physics

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...