Let P(x) be a predicate. Which of the following is NOT valid in first-order logic?
Solution :
The correct options that are NOT valid in first-order logic are:
1.
2.
3.
Understanding Validity in First-Order Logic
In first-order logic, a statement is considered valid if it evaluates to true under every possible interpretation over any non-empty domain of discourse. If we can find at least one interpretation (a counterexample) where the statement evaluates to false, then the statement is not valid (invalid).
Let us analyze each of the given statements step-by-step:
1. Analyzing the Statement:
This statement claims that if the predicate is true for all elements in the domain, then there must exist some element for which is false.
Let us construct a counterexample:
- Let the domain be .
- Let be true.
Under this interpretation, the antecedent is true because holds for every element in the domain. However, the consequent is false because there is no element in the domain for which is false. The implication becomes:
which evaluates to false. Thus, this statement is NOT valid.
2. Analyzing the Statement:
This statement claims that if there exists at least one element for which is true, then must be true for all elements in the domain.
Let us construct a counterexample:
- Let the domain be .
- Let be true and be false.
Under this interpretation, the antecedent is true (since is true). However, the consequent is false (since is false). The implication becomes:
which evaluates to false. Thus, this statement is NOT valid.
3. Analyzing the Statement:
An equivalence is valid only if and are both valid. Since we have already shown that the direction is invalid, the equivalence is also NOT valid.
4. Note on the Valid Option:
Under standard first-order logic, the domain of discourse is assumed to be non-empty. If a property holds for all elements in a non-empty domain, it must hold for at least one element. Therefore, this implication is always true, making it a valid statement.
Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.
Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.
Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.
Prepare for GATE 2026 Civil Engineering with the latest question papers, previous year papers, detailed solutions, syllabus, exam pattern, preparation tips, mock tests, and subject-wise study material. Download GATE 2026 CE question papers with solutions in PDF format and boost your preparation for top engineering institutes and PSU recruitment.
Prepare effectively for GATE 2026 Electronics & Communication Engineering (EC) with this comprehensive Question Paper with Solutions. This resource includes detailed explanations, concept-wise solutions, previous year paper analysis, and exam-oriented practice to help aspirants strengthen core subjects like Electronic Devices, Analog Circuits, Digital Circuits, Signals & Systems, Network Theory, Control Systems, Electromagnetics, Communications, and more. Perfect for revision, self-assessment, and boosting your GATE 2026 EC preparation strategy.
Copyright © 2026 Combe Labs Private Limited. All Rights Reserved.