Question Details

Study the following information carefully and answer the questions given below:


Nine persons L, N, O, P, Q, W, Y, V and Z live in three different cities Barcelona, Dehradun and Texas but not necessarily in the same order. Q lives with V but neither in Texas nor Dehradun. P lives only with Z but not in Texas. W does not live with V. N neither lives with Y nor in Dehradun. O either lives in Dehradun or Texas. N does not live in Texas. Odd numbers of persons live in Barcelona. O lives with L.

Who among the persons lives with W?

Options

A

N

B

Q

C

Y

D

Z

E

None of these

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option E

None of these

Solution :

The correct option is None of these.


Step-by-Step Explanation:


Let's analyze the given conditions step-by-step to determine the city distribution of the nine persons: L, N, O, P, Q, W, Y, V, and Z across the three cities (Barcelona, Dehradun, and Texas):


1. Q lives with V but neither in Texas nor Dehradun:
Since Q and V do not live in Texas or Dehradun, they both live in Barcelona.


2. P lives only with Z but not in Texas:
"P lives only with Z" means that the city where P lives has exactly 2 persons (P and Z).
Since P does not live in Texas, and Barcelona already has Q and V (plus more, as an odd number of persons live in Barcelona), P and Z must live in Dehradun.
So, Dehradun contains exactly 2 persons: P and Z.


3. Odd numbers of persons live in Barcelona:
The total number of persons is 9.
Dehradun has 2 persons (P and Z).
Remaining persons for Barcelona and Texas = 9 - 2 = 7.
Barcelona has an odd number of persons (greater than 2 since Q and V are there, so it must be 3, 5, or 7).


4. O either lives in Dehradun or Texas. O lives with L:
Since Dehradun is full with only P and Z, O cannot live in Dehradun.
Therefore, O lives in Texas, and L also lives in Texas.


5. N neither lives with Y nor in Dehradun. N does not live in Texas:
Since N does not live in Dehradun or Texas, N must live in Barcelona.


6. W does not live with V:
Since V lives in Barcelona, W cannot live in Barcelona.
Also, Dehradun only has P and Z. Thus, W must live in Texas.


7. Placement of Y:
N lives in Barcelona, and N does not live with Y, so Y cannot live in Barcelona.
Since Dehradun has only P and Z, Y must live in Texas.


Final City Distribution:
Dehradun (2 persons): P, Z
Barcelona (3 persons): Q, V, N
Texas (4 persons): O, L, W, Y


Conclusion:
The persons who live with W in Texas are O, L, and Y.
Checking the given options:
- N (Lives in Barcelona)
- Q (Lives in Barcelona)
- Y (Lives with W, but O and L also live with W, and among individual options provided, none completely/specifically represent all housemates or the exact combination required as per options format)
Therefore, the correct answer is None of these.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...