Question Details

On the night of October 12th, the ”Sunburst Medallion” was stolen from the highly secured display case in the city museum. The theft occurred sometime between the museum closing at 10:00 PM and the night guard, Mr. Hemant, completing his final round at 1:00 AM. Three primary suspects were identified, all of whom had recently been dismissed from their museum positions: Anjali, the former curator; Bharat, the former security expert; and Chitra, the former exhibits designer.
Here are the established facts and their alibis:
• The security system logs show that the display case was opened using a specific five-digit code, which only Anjali and the museum director (who was out of the country) knew.
• Bharat’s alibi is that he was at a distant relative’s birthday party from 8:00 PM to 1:30 AM. Multiple independent witnesses confirmed his presence throughout the entire period.
• Chitra’s alibi is that she was working late at a downtown graphic design studio. A timestamped security camera from the studio’s entrance shows her entering at 7:00 PM and exiting at 11:45 PM. The studio is a 20-minute drive from the museum.
• Mr. Hemant, the night guard, stated he checked the medallion at 10:30 PM, and it was still there.
• Further investigation revealed that a small, distinctive silver button was found near the display case. Anjali is known to frequently wear a coat with similar unique silver buttons. The security expert, Bharat, had previously boasted that he could remotely disable a
certain type of magnetic lock-the same type used on the medallion’s case-without needing the code, though the log suggests the code was used. (269 words)


Identifying the Logical Flaw in the Argument :
A detective argues: ”Since Bharat has a confirmed, continuous alibi covering the entire time window of the theft (10:30 PM to 1:00 AM), he cannot be the thief.” What principle of logic supports this detective’s conclusion?

Options

A

Correlation does not imply causation

B

If an event requires presence, confirmed absence proves innocence

C

The rule of double jeopardy

D

The burden of proof lies with the accuser

Show Answer
Correct Answer
B If an event requires presence, confirmed absence proves innocence

Solution :

Correct Answer: If an event requires presence, confirmed absence proves innocence


Step-by-Step Explanation:


1. Understanding the Detective's Argument:
The detective claims that because Bharat was verified to be at another location (a birthday party) continuously from 8:00 PM to 1:30 AM, he could not have committed the physical theft at the museum which occurred between 10:30 PM and 1:00 AM.


2. Identifying the Underlying Logical Principle:
The act of stealing an item directly from a physical display case requires physical presence at the scene at the time of the crime. Logically, if a crime requires physical presence (Event P requires Presence X), and it is definitively proven that a person was absent from that place during that timeframe (Not Presence X), then that person could not have performed the physical act (Not Event P).


3. Evaluating the Options:

• Correlation does not imply causation: Refers to confusing sequential or simultaneous events with causal relationships, which is irrelevant to proof by alibi.
• If an event requires presence, confirmed absence proves innocence: This directly describes Modus Tollens applied to presence and action (If P, then Q; Not Q, therefore Not P). Confirmed absence invalidates the necessary condition for committing the physical theft.
• The rule of double jeopardy: A legal protection preventing someone from being tried twice for the same crime, unrelated to evaluating alibis.
• The burden of proof lies with the accuser: A legal standard regarding who must prove a claim, not a principle explaining why an alibi logically eliminates a suspect.


Thus, the detective's conclusion relies on the fundamental logical principle: "If an event requires presence, confirmed absence proves innocence".

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: