Question Details

Each question consists of legal propositions/ principles (hereinafter referred to as 'principle') and facts. These principles have to be applied to the given facts to arrive at the most reasonable conclusion. Such principles may or may not be true in the real sense, yet you have to conclusively assume them to be true for the purposes of this section. In other words, in answering the following questions, you must not rely on any principles except the principles that are given herein below for every question. Further, you must not assume any facts other than those stated in the question. The objective of this section is to test your interest towards study of law, research aptitude and problem solving ability even if the 'most reasonable conclusion' arrived at may be unacceptable for any other reason. It is not the object of this section to test your knowledge of law.



PRINCIPLE: Master is liable for the wrongful acts committed by his servant; provided the acts are committed during the course of employment. However, the master is not liable if the wrongful act committed by his servant has no connection, whatsoever, with the servant's contract of employment.



FACTS: 'D' is a driver employed by 'M', who is the owner of a company. During the lunch time, 'D' goes to a closely tea shop to have a cup of tea. There he ('D') picks up fight with the tea shop owner ('T'), which resulted in some damage to his shop. T wants to sue 'M' for claiming compensation for the damage a used by the fight.



Which of the following derivations is CORRECT?

Options

A

'M' will be liable because 'D' is his servant

B

Both 'M' and 'D' will be liable

C

'M' will not be liable because the wrongful act (picking up fight) was not committed in the course of D's employment

D

'M' will be liable albeit the wrongful act (picking up fight) was not committed in the course of D's employment

Show Answer
Correct Answer
C 'M' will not be liable because the wrongful act (picking up fight) was not committed in the course of D's employment

Solution :

The correct answer is: 'M' will not be liable because the wrongful act (picking up fight) was not committed in the course of D's employment.

Let us carefully break down the principle and apply it to the given facts step by step.

Step 1: Understand the Legal Principle

The principle has two parts:
  (a) A master is liable for wrongful acts of his servant if those acts are committed during the course of employment.
  (b) A master is NOT liable if the wrongful act has no connection whatsoever with the servant's contract of employment.

This principle is rooted in the legal doctrine of vicarious liability — a master answers for the wrongs of his servant, but only within the boundaries of the servant's employment duties.

Step 2: Identify the Key Facts

  â€˘ 'D' is a driver employed by 'M', the owner of a company.
  â€˘ During lunch time, 'D' goes to a nearby tea shop on his own initiative — to have a cup of tea.
  â€˘ At the tea shop, 'D' picks up a fight with the tea shop owner 'T', causing damage to T's shop.
  â€˘ 'T' wants to sue 'M' for compensation.

Step 3: Was 'D' Acting in the Course of Employment?

This is the central question. 'D's contract of employment is to drive for 'M'. The act of going to a tea shop during lunch and picking up a fight is:

  â€˘ Not a driving-related activity — it has nothing to do with D's role as a driver.
  â€˘ A purely personal activity — having tea during lunch is entirely outside the scope of D's employment duties.
  â€˘ The fight itself is a personal altercation with absolutely no connection to D's work or M's company business.

Step 4: Apply the Principle to the Facts

Since the wrongful act (picking a fight with 'T') was committed:
  (i) During D's personal lunch break,
  (ii) At a location chosen by D for his own personal purpose,
  (iii) With no connection whatsoever to his employment as a driver for 'M',

...the second part of the principle is triggered: "the master is not liable if the wrongful act committed by his servant has no connection, whatsoever, with the servant's contract of employment."

Step 5: Conclusion

'M' cannot be held vicariously liable for D's personal conduct at the tea shop. The principle of master-servant liability only extends to acts performed within the course and scope of employment. The moment 'D' stepped away from his employment duties to pursue a personal activity and then committed a wrongful act during that personal activity, 'M's liability ceased entirely.

Therefore, 'M' will not be liable for the damage caused to T's shop, because the wrongful act had no connection with D's employment as a driver. 'T' may, however, proceed against 'D' personally for the damage caused.

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: