Question Details

Each question consists of legal propositions/ principles (hereinafter referred to as 'principle') and facts. These principles have to be applied to the given facts to arrive at the most reasonable conclusion. Such principles may or may not be true in the real sense, yet you have to conclusively assume them to be true for the purposes of this section. In other words, in answering the following questions, you must not rely on any principles except the principles that are given herein below for every question. Further, you must not assume any facts other than those stated in the question. The objective of this section is to test your interest towards study of law, research aptitude and problem solving ability even if the 'most reasonable conclusion' arrived at may be unacceptable for any other reason. It is not the object of this section to test your knowledge of law.


PRINCIPLE: No communication made in good faith is an offence by reason of any harm to the person to whom it is made, if it is made for the benefit of that person.


FACTS: 'A', a surgeon, in good faith, communicates to a patient hiopinion that he cannot live. The patient dies in consequence of the shock.

Options

A

'A' has committed the offence of causing death of his patient

B

'A' has not committed the offence of causing death of his patient

C

'A' has only partially committed the offence of causing death of his patient

D

None of the above.

Show Answer
Correct Answer
B 'A' has not committed the offence of causing death of his patient

Solution :

The correct answer is: 'A' has not committed the offence of causing death of his patient.

Let us carefully break down the principle and the facts step by step to arrive at this conclusion.

Step 1: Understanding the Principle

The principle states: "No communication made in good faith is an offence by reason of any harm to the person to whom it is made, if it is made for the benefit of that person."

This principle has three essential conditions that must all be satisfied for a communication to be protected (i.e., not treated as an offence):

1. The communication must be made in good faith.
2. The communication must be made for the benefit of the person receiving it.
3. Any harm caused must arise solely by reason of that communication.

If all three conditions are met, the person making the communication cannot be held liable for the resulting harm.

Step 2: Applying the Principle to the Facts

Now let us examine each condition against the given facts:

Condition 1 — Good Faith:
The facts explicitly state that surgeon 'A' communicated his opinion "in good faith." There is no indication of any malicious intent, negligence, or dishonesty. The very word "good faith" is used in the problem. ✔ This condition is satisfied.

Condition 2 — For the Benefit of the Patient:
A surgeon informing a patient of his prognosis — even a fatal one — is acting for that patient's benefit. Such communication allows the patient to make informed decisions: to settle personal affairs, meet loved ones, seek a second opinion, or prepare mentally and spiritually. Truthful medical communication, however painful, serves the patient's interest. ✔ This condition is satisfied.

Condition 3 — Harm Arising from the Communication:
The patient dies as a consequence of the shock caused by the news. The harm (death) did arise from the communication. However, the principle explicitly covers such situations — it says no communication made in good faith for the person's benefit is an offence by reason of any harm to that person. The harm resulting from the communication does not convert it into an offence, provided the other two conditions are met. ✔ This condition is accounted for by the principle.

Step 3: Conclusion

All three conditions of the protective principle are fulfilled in 'A's case. The surgeon communicated in good faith, for the benefit of the patient. Even though the patient died as a result of the shock from the news, this does not make the communication an offence under the given principle.

Therefore, 'A' has NOT committed the offence of causing death of his patient. The principle acts as a complete shield against liability in this scenario.

Why the other options are incorrect:

• Option 1 ("'A' has committed the offence") is wrong because the principle directly exonerates 'A' — all conditions for protection are met.
• Option 3 ("only partially committed the offence") is wrong because the principle does not create any concept of partial liability; once its conditions are met, the communication is entirely not an offence.
• Option 4 ("None of the above") is wrong because Option 2 is a valid and correct conclusion.

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: