Question Details

Each question consists of legal propositions/ principles (hereinafter referred to as 'principle') and facts. These principles have to be applied to the given facts to arrive at the most reasonable conclusion. Such principles may or may not be true in the real sense, yet you have to conclusively assume them to be true for the purposes of this section. In other words, in answering the following questions, you must not rely on any principles except the principles that are given herein below for every question. Further, you must not assume any facts other than those stated in the question. The objective of this section is to test your interest towards study of law, research aptitude and problem solving ability even if the 'most reasonable conclusion' arrived at may be unacceptable for any other reason. It is not the object of this section to test your knowledge of law.


PRINCIPLE: The Constitution of India guarantees the 'right to life', which means 'right to live with human dignity'. The right to life under the Constitution, however, does not include the right to die.

FACTS: 'M', who is 90, lives all alone as he has no family or children or grandchildren. He suffers from physical and mental distress, as there is no one to look after him. He has little means to foot his medical expenses. Under these circumstances, he approaches the court with a prayer that he should be granted the right to die with dignity because he does not want to be a burden on the society. Further, as it is his life, he has a right to put an end to it.



Which of the following derivations is CORRECT?

Options

A

The prayer can be granted, as suicide is not an offence in India

B

The prayer can be granted, as the right to life under the Constitution includes the right to die

C

The prayer can be granted, as a person cannot be forced to enjoy right to life to his detriment, disadvantage and disliking

D

The prayer cannot be granted, as the right to life under the Constitution does not include the right to die.

Show Answer
Correct Answer
D The prayer cannot be granted, as the right to life under the Constitution does not include the right to die.

Solution :

The correct answer is: "The prayer cannot be granted, as the right to life under the Constitution does not include the right to die."

Let us carefully analyze the principle and the facts, and then evaluate why this is the only legally correct conclusion.

Step 1: Identify and Understand the Governing Principle

The principle explicitly states two things:
1. The Constitution of India guarantees the right to life, which means the right to live with human dignity.
2. Critically: The right to life under the Constitution does NOT include the right to die.

This principle is the supreme rule we must apply. We cannot deviate from it, add to it, or override it with personal reasoning or external legal knowledge.

Step 2: Understand the Facts

'M' is a 90-year-old individual who:
- Lives alone with no family support
- Suffers from physical and mental distress
- Has limited means to pay for medical care
- Approaches the court seeking the right to die with dignity, arguing he does not wish to be a burden on society and that it is his life to end

M's prayer is essentially a request for the legal recognition of the right to die.

Step 3: Apply the Principle to the Facts

No matter how sympathetic M's circumstances are — his age, loneliness, distress, and financial hardship — the governing principle is unambiguous: the right to life does not include the right to die. This is the boundary the principle draws, and we are instructed to treat it as conclusively true.

M's argument that "it is his life and he has a right to put an end to it" is a personal moral claim, but it has no legal basis under the stated principle. The right to life, as defined here, is a positive right — a right to live with dignity — and does not transform into a negative right to terminate life.

Step 4: Evaluate and Eliminate the Incorrect Options

Option 1 — "The prayer can be granted, as suicide is not an offence in India": This introduces an external legal fact (decriminalization of suicide) which we are forbidden from assuming. We must rely only on the given principle, which does not mention this. This option is incorrect.

Option 2 — "The prayer can be granted, as the right to life includes the right to die": This directly contradicts the stated principle, which explicitly says the right to life does not include the right to die. This option is incorrect.

Option 3 — "The prayer can be granted, as a person cannot be forced to enjoy the right to life to his detriment": This argument, while emotionally appealing, is a philosophical interpretation that goes beyond the principle. The principle does not grant any such exception. We must not assume facts or extend principles beyond what is stated. This option is incorrect.

Option 4 — "The prayer cannot be granted, as the right to life under the Constitution does not include the right to die": This directly and faithfully applies the stated principle to the facts. Since M's prayer is for the right to die, and the principle clearly excludes this from the scope of the right to life, the court cannot grant his prayer. This option is correct.

Conclusion

The key skill tested here is strict application of the given principle, not sympathy for the petitioner or independent legal knowledge. Despite M's genuinely difficult circumstances, the principle forms an absolute bar. The court must reject the prayer because the constitutional right to life, as defined in the principle, does not encompass the right to die — and no other external consideration can override this stated rule.

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: