Question Details

Six boxes - A, B, C, D, E and F are placed one above another. These boxes are of different types – Jute, Steel, Iron, Wood, Leather, Brass. All the information is not necessarily in the same order.

Box D is placed three places above leather box. Same number of boxes are placed above box D and below steel box. Box B is placed just below box F and juts above wood box. Box A is placed two places below iron box. More than one box is placed below box C which is placed below brass box.

Which of the following statement is incorrect?

Options

A

Box E is bottommost box

B

Box B is leather box

C

Box D is placed above box F

D

Box A and B are adjacent to each other

E

Box C is brass box

Show Answer
Correct Answer
E Box C is brass box

Solution :

The correct statement that is incorrect (i.e. false) is Box C is brass box.


Step-by-Step Explanation:


Let us determine the exact arrangement of the 6 boxes (numbered 6 at the top to 1 at the bottom) and their respective material types based on the given clues:


1. Clue 1: "Box D is placed three places above leather box."
This means Box D is at a position such that if Leather box is at position k, Box D is at position k+3 (i.e., there are two boxes between Box D and the Leather box).


2. Clue 2: "Same number of boxes are placed above box D and below steel box."
If Box D is at position 6, Steel box is at position 1.
If Box D is at position 5, Steel box is at position 2.
If Box D is at position 4, Steel box is at position 3.


3. Clue 3: "Box B is placed just below box F and just above wood box."
This gives a consecutive block of three boxes from top to bottom: F, B, Wood box.


4. Clue 4: "Box A is placed two places below iron box."
This means Iron box is 2 places above Box A (i.e., Iron box, then one box, then Box A).


5. Clue 5: "More than one box is placed below box C which is placed below brass box."
Since more than one box is placed below Box C, Box C cannot be at position 1 or position 2. So Box C must be at position 3 or higher, but below the Brass box.


Deducing the Box Positions:

Let's test the positions for Box D:

Case A: If Box D is at position 6 (topmost):
- Leather box is 3 places below, so Leather box is at position 3.
- Steel box is at position 1 (bottommost, since 0 boxes are above D, so 0 boxes below Steel).
- Now we need to place the block F - B - Wood.
- If F is at position 5, B is at 4, Wood is at 3. But position 3 is already Leather box! Contradiction.
- If F is at position 4, B is at 3 (Leather), Wood is at 2. Then Box A must be placed. But Box A is 2 places below Iron. The remaining positions for boxes are 5, 2, 1. If A is at 2 or 1, Iron could be at 4 (Box F) or 3 (Box B). Let's check:
- If Box C is placed, since C is below Brass and >1 box is below C, Box C must be at position 3 or 4. But positions 6 (D), 4 (F), 3 (B), 2 (Wood), 1 (Steel) leaves 5 for C. Position 5 has 4 boxes below it, which satisfies >1 box below C.
- Let's check the remaining clues: F (pos 4), B (pos 3), Wood (pos 2). Box A is 2 places below Iron box. The available boxes for A and E are pos 5 and 1 or 2. If A is at pos 1, Iron is at pos 3 (B is Iron). But B is Leather! Contradiction.


Case B: If Box D is at position 5:
- Leather box is at position 2.
- Steel box is at position 2 (since 1 box is above D, 1 box is below Steel). But position 2 is already Leather box! Contradiction (a box cannot be both Leather and Steel).


Case C: If Box D is at position 4:
- Leather box is 3 places below D, so Leather box is at position 1.
- 2 boxes are above D, so 2 boxes are below Steel box. Thus, Steel box is at position 3.
- Now place block F - B - Wood:
- Since positions 4, 3, 1 are taken by D, Steel (pos 3), Leather (pos 1), the remaining continuous 3 spots for F - B - Wood must be positions 6, 5, 4? No, pos 4 is D.
- What about positions 6, 5, 4? Position 4 is D, so that doesn't work.
- What if F is at position 6, B is at position 5, and Wood box is at position 4 (Box D)? That works perfectly!
- Position 6: Box F
- Position 5: Box B
- Position 4: Box D (Wood box)
- Position 3: Steel box
- Position 2: ?
- Position 1: Leather box


Let's complete Case C:
- Positions 3 and 2 are left for Box A and Box C, or Box E.
- Clue 4: Box A is two places below Iron box.
- If Box A is at position 3, then Iron box must be at position 5 (Box B).
- If Box A is at position 2, then Iron box must be at position 4 (Box D). But Box D is Wood box! So Box A cannot be at position 2.
- Therefore, Box A is at position 3 (Steel box), and Box B (position 5) is the Iron box.
- Now positions left for boxes C and E are 2 and 1.
- Clue 5: "More than one box is placed below box C which is placed below brass box."
- If Box C is at position 2, there is only 1 box below it (position 1). But the clue says "More than one box is placed below box C".
- Wait, let's re-verify position options for C. Could Box C be at position 4? No, position 4 is D. Position 5 is B. Position 6 is F.
- What if Box C is at position 6 (Brass box above it? No, nothing above 6).


Let's re-evaluate position 6 for Box D:
- D at position 5: Leather at 2, Steel at 2 (conflict).
- D at position 4: 2 boxes above D (positions 5, 6). 2 boxes below Steel => Steel is at position 3.
- Leather is at position 1 (3 places below D).
- Block F - B - Wood: F=6, B=5, Wood=4 (D).
- Box A is 2 places below Iron: Iron=5 (B), A=3 (Steel).
- Remaining box positions: 2 and 1.
- Remaining boxes: C and E.
- If C is at position 2: boxes below C = 1 (which is NOT more than 1).
- What if F=5, B=4... no D is at 4.
- Let's check D at position 6:
- 0 boxes above D => 0 boxes below Steel => Steel at position 1.
- Leather is 3 places below D => Leather at position 3.
- Block F - B - Wood:
- If F=5, B=4, Wood=3 (Leather? Leather is a type, so Box B at 4 is above Wood box at 3 (Leather)). This works! Box at position 3 is Leather and Wood? No, each box is of ONE type.
- Ah! "just below box F and just above wood box". So Box B is at 4, Wood box is at 3. But position 3 is Leather! A box cannot be both Wood and Leather. So F cannot be 5.
- Wait! What if Leather is at position 3, and block F - B - Wood is at positions 4 - 3 - 2? That means F=4, B=3 (Leather box), Wood=2.
- Pos 6: Box D
- Pos 5: ?
- Pos 4: Box F
- Pos 3: Box B (Leather)
- Pos 2: Wood box
- Pos 1: Steel box
- Let's check Box A (2 places below Iron):
- If A is at pos 2, Iron is pos 4 (Box F).
- If A is at pos 1 (Steel), Iron is pos 3 (Box B).
- If A is at pos 5, Iron cannot be 7.
- Let's check Box C ("More than one box is placed below box C which is placed below brass box"):
- C must have >1 box below it, so C can be at pos 5 or pos 4.
- If C is at pos 5: boxes below C = 4 (>1). C is below Brass box, so Box D (pos 6) must be Brass box!
- If C is at pos 5, then Box A must be at pos 2 (Wood box) or pos 1 (Steel box).
- Since C is at pos 5, remaining spots for A and E are 2 and 1.
- If Box A is at pos 2, Iron box is pos 4 (Box F).
- Then Box E is at pos 1 (Steel box).
- Let's check all conditions for this complete arrangement:
- Pos 6: Box D (Brass)
- Pos 5: Box C (Jute/Iron)
- Pos 4: Box F (Iron)
- Pos 3: Box B (Leather)
- Pos 2: Box A (Wood)
- Pos 1: Box E (Steel)


Verification of the Final Arrangement:

1. Box D (pos 6) is 3 places above Leather box (pos 3, Box B). (Correct)
2. Same number of boxes above D (0) and below Steel box (0 below pos 1, Box E). (Correct)
3. Box B (pos 3) is just below Box F (pos 4) and just above Wood box (pos 2, Box A). (Correct)
4. Box A (pos 2) is 2 places below Iron box (pos 4, Box F). (Correct)
5. Box C (pos 5) has 4 boxes below it (>1 box) and is below Brass box (pos 6, Box D). (Correct)
6. Remaining material for Box C is Jute.


Checking the Options:

1. Box E is bottommost box: True (Box E is at position 1).
2. Box B is leather box: True (Box B is at position 3, Leather).
3. Box D is placed above box F: True (Box D is at position 6, Box F is at position 4).
4. Box A and B are adjacent to each other: True (Box B is at position 3, Box A is at position 2).
5. Box C is brass box: INCORRECT / FALSE (Box C is Jute box, while Box D is Brass box).


Therefore, the incorrect statement is Box C is brass box.

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: