‘Sound is eternal because it is produced’ refers to which of the following Hetvabhasa?
Solution :
The correct option is Asiddha.
In Classical Indian Philosophy (specifically Nyaya logic), Hetvabhasa refers to a fallacy of inference. An inference (Anumana) is fallacious when the reason (hetu) given to prove a claim is not valid.
Let us analyze the structure of the given statement: "Sound is eternal because it is produced."
- Paksha (Subject): Sound
- Sadhya (Object to be proven): Eternal (imperishable)
- Hetu (Reason): Produced (having a beginning/origin)
The fallacy here is Asiddha (also known as Sadhyasama), which translates to the "unproved middle." This fallacy occurs when the reason (hetu) is not present in the subject (paksha), or when the relation between the subject and the reason is not established. However, in this specific case, it illustrates the subtype of Asiddha where the middle term itself is unproved or does not exist in a way that can prove the major term (eternality), because what is "produced" is universally understood to be non-eternal (temporary). Since the character of being "produced" contradicts "eternality" directly and cannot coexist, the reason fails to establish the claim, making the argument fallacious under Asiddha (specifically, the reason given cannot prove the property of being eternal).
Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.
Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.
Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.
Prepare effectively for the UPSC Civil Services Examination with the UPSC Prelims 2016 Paper 2 (CSAT) Question Paper with Detailed Solutions. This paper includes all original CSAT questions from the UPSC Prelims 2016 examination along with step-by-step explanations, answer keys, and shortcut techniques.The UPSC CSAT paper tests candidates on Comprehension, Logical Reasoning, Analytical Ability, Decision Making, Basic Numeracy, Data Interpretation, and Mental Ability. Solving previous year question papers is one of the best ways to understand the exam pattern, improve accuracy, and enhance time management skills.
Prepare for the UPSC Civil Services Examination with the UPSC Prelims 2017 Paper 2 (CSAT) Question Paper and detailed solutions. This solved paper provides clear explanations and step-by-step approaches to every question, helping aspirants improve comprehension, logical reasoning, analytical ability, decision-making, basic numeracy, and data interpretation skills. It is an excellent resource for understanding the CSAT exam pattern, enhancing problem-solving techniques, and building confidence for future UPSC Preliminary Examinations.
Copyright © 2026 Combe Labs Private Limited. All Rights Reserved.