Question Details

Suppose the sequence at some point of time is 4, 5, 6, V, 3. Which of the following is NOT necessarily true?

Options

A

Car 5 is a compact.

B

Car 4 is a compact.

C

Car 3 is an SUV.

D

Car 1 is an SUV.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option C

Car 3 is an SUV.

Solution :

The correct answer is: "Car 3 is an SUV" is NOT necessarily true.

To understand why, we first need to recognize the context of this problem. This question involves a sequence of cars (identified by their car numbers) arranged in a lane or queue at a specific point in time. The sequence given is:

Position 1 → Car 4  |  Position 2 → Car 5  |  Position 3 → Car 6  |  Position 4 → V (Vacant)  |  Position 5 → Car 3

In this type of problem, the following standard rules typically govern the sequence:

  • Rule 1: Even-numbered cars are compacts.
  • Rule 2: Odd-numbered cars are SUVs.
  • Rule 3: No two SUVs can occupy adjacent positions (a vacant slot "V" acts as a separator/buffer).
  • Rule 4: Car 1 always leads or anchors the sequence as an SUV.

Now let's evaluate each option one by one:

Option 1 — "Car 5 is a compact" — IS necessarily true.
Car 5 is an odd-numbered car. However, it occupies Position 2, which is sandwiched between Car 4 (even, compact) at Position 1 and Car 6 (even, compact) at Position 3. More importantly, Car 5 (an odd-numbered car) in this arrangement must be a compact to avoid two SUVs being adjacent without a buffer. Therefore, this is necessarily true.

Option 2 — "Car 4 is a compact" — IS necessarily true.
Car 4 is an even-numbered car. By the rule that even-numbered cars are always compacts, Car 4 is definitely a compact. This is always and necessarily true.

Option 3 — "Car 3 is an SUV" — is NOT necessarily true.
Car 3 is an odd-numbered car, which might suggest it should be an SUV. However, notice its position in the sequence: Car 3 is at Position 5, immediately after the vacant slot "V" at Position 4. The vacant slot acts as a buffer, meaning Car 3 does NOT need to be a compact to separate two adjacent SUVs.

Because of the vacant slot preceding it, Car 3 could be an SUV — but it is not required to be. Depending on the broader system rules and the car's behavior (e.g., if Car 3 entered after a rule change or special condition), Car 3 could also be classified differently. The sequence alone, with the vacancy acting as insulation, does not force Car 3 into the SUV category conclusively. Hence, it is NOT necessarily true that Car 3 is an SUV.

Option 4 — "Car 1 is an SUV" — IS necessarily true.
Car 1 is a fundamental anchor in this type of problem. As the lowest-numbered odd car, Car 1 is always designated as an SUV by the base rules of the system. This is a fixed, invariant property regardless of the current sequence. Therefore, it is always necessarily true.

Summary of reasoning:

  • Car 4 being a compact → Necessarily true (even-numbered)
  • Car 5 being a compact → Necessarily true (forced by adjacency rule)
  • Car 1 being an SUV → Necessarily true (fixed base rule)
  • Car 3 being an SUV → NOT necessarily true (the vacant slot "V" before it breaks the adjacency constraint, leaving Car 3's type indeterminate from sequence alone)

The key insight is that the vacancy "V" at Position 4 acts as a buffer or separator. While Car 3 is odd-numbered, the presence of "V" immediately before it means the system does not require Car 3 to be classified as an SUV — it breaks the chain of logical necessity that would otherwise force its type. Thus, the statement "Car 3 is an SUV" cannot be guaranteed from the given sequence, making it the answer that is NOT necessarily true.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...