Question Details

The argument, 'Sound is eternal, because it is produced', is fallacious because:

Options

A

Middle term is contradicted by another pramana (means of knowledge).

B

The middle term is too narrow.

C

Middle term itself disproves the original proposition and proves its contradictory..

D

The minor term is the locus of the middle term.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option C

Middle term itself disproves the original proposition and proves its contradictory..

Solution :

The correct option is: Middle term itself disproves the original proposition and proves its contradictory..

To understand why this argument is fallacious, let us break down the structure of the syllogism according to classical Indian logic (Nyaya):
1. Minor Term (Paksha): "Sound" (the subject about which the assertion is made).
2. Major Term (Sadhya): "Eternal" (the property that we are trying to prove about the subject).
3. Middle Term (Hetu): "Produced" (the reason or ground given to prove the assertion).

For an argument to be valid, the middle term must be logically compatible with the major term. However, in this case, the property of being "produced" (krtakatva) is incompatible with being "eternal" (nitya). In fact, whatever is produced or created must have a beginning and an end, which means it is necessarily non-eternal (anitya).

Thus, instead of proving that sound is eternal, the middle term ("produced") actually establishes the contradictory proposition: that sound is non-eternal. In Nyaya philosophy, this fallacy is called Viruddha (the contradictory middle), where the hetu directly refutes the sadhya it is intended to prove.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...