The number of persons who read magazine X only is thrice the number of persons who read magazine Y. The number of persons who read magazine Y only is thrice the number of persons who read magazine X. Then, which of the following conclusions can be drawn?
1. The number of persons who read both the magazines is twice the number of persons who read only magazine X.
2. The total number of persons who read either one magazine or both the magazines is twice the number of persons who read both the magazines.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
Solution :
The correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
To understand why this is the correct choice, let us define the number of persons in each category using algebraic variables:
Let
be the number of persons who read magazine X only.
Let
be the number of persons who read magazine Y only.
Let
be the number of persons who read both magazines X and Y.
From these definitions, we can express the total number of persons who read each magazine:
The number of persons who read magazine X is:
The number of persons who read magazine Y is:
Now, we convert the statements given in the question into algebraic equations.
First Condition: "The number of persons who read magazine X only is thrice the number of persons who read magazine Y."
This gives us:
This can be expanded to:
(Equation 1)
Second Condition: "The number of persons who read magazine Y only is thrice the number of persons who read magazine X."
This gives us:
This can be expanded to:
(Equation 2)
Let us solve the system of equations by subtracting Equation 2 from Equation 1:
Simplifying the right side:
Rearranging the terms:
Substituting
back into Equation 1:
Subtracting
from both sides:
Solving for
:
Since the number of persons in any category cannot be negative (
and
), the only mathematically valid solution is:
In any scenario with a non-zero reader base, these conditions are contradictory. Thus, no consistent positive integer solution exists.
Even if we analyze the assertions based on the relations:
Evaluating Conclusion 1: "The number of persons who read both the magazines is twice the number of persons who read only magazine X."
This requires
. However, our derivation shows that
. Therefore, Conclusion 1 does not hold.
Evaluating Conclusion 2: "The total number of persons who read either one magazine or both the magazines is twice the number of persons who read both the magazines."
The total number of persons is
. Since
, the total is
.
For this conclusion to be correct:
This also contradicts our relationship where
. Thus, Conclusion 2 does not hold.
Consequently, neither Conclusion 1 nor Conclusion 2 can be logically drawn.
Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.
Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.
Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.
A comprehensive SSC MTS 2026 Mock Test 4 designed to help aspirants strengthen their preparation and improve their performance for the Staff Selection Commission Multi-Tasking Staff examination. This mock test covers all major sections including Numerical and Mathematical Ability, Reasoning Ability and Problem Solving, General Awareness, and English Language and Comprehension. It includes a balanced combination of conceptual, analytical, and exam-oriented multiple-choice questions aligned with the latest SSC MTS syllabus and exam pattern. Ideal for practice, revision, self-evaluation, accuracy improvement, speed enhancement, and effective time management, this mock test helps candidates assess their exam readiness, identify improvement areas, and build confidence for the SSC MTS 2026 examination
A comprehensive SSC MTS 2026 Mock Test 3 designed to help aspirants prepare thoroughly for the Staff Selection Commission Multi-Tasking Staff examination. This mock test covers all important sections including Numerical and Mathematical Ability, Reasoning Ability and Problem Solving, General Awareness, and English Language and Comprehension. It features a carefully curated set of multiple-choice questions that test conceptual understanding, logical reasoning, problem-solving skills, speed, and accuracy in accordance with the latest SSC MTS exam pattern. Ideal for practice, revision, self-assessment, performance evaluation, and time management improvement, this mock test enables candidates to identify strengths and weaknesses while building confidence for the SSC MTS 2026 examination.
Copyright © 2026 Combe Labs Private Limited. All Rights Reserved.