Six boxes — A, B, C, D, E and F — are kept one above another in a stack, but not necessarily in the same order. How many boxes are kept above box D?
Statement I: Only two boxes are kept below box E. Only one box is kept between box E and box B. Box C is kept immediately above box B. Box D is kept above box F but below box A.
Statement II: Box C is kept four boxes above box F. Box C and box A are kept adjacent to each other. More than two boxes are kept between box A and box E. Box B is kept below box D.
The question below consists of two statements numbered I and II given below it. You have to decide whether the data provided in the statement is sufficient to answer the question.
Solution :
The correct answer is: Data given in statement II alone is sufficient to answer.
Let's analyze the problem step-by-step to determine the sufficiency of the statements. We have six boxes: A, B, C, D, E, and F kept one above another in a stack (positions 1 to 6 from bottom to top, or 6 to 1 from top to bottom).
Analyzing Statement I:
1. "Only two boxes are kept below box E." This means E is at the 3rd position from the bottom (Position 3). Let's denote positions from 6 (top) to 1 (bottom):
Position 6:
Position 5:
Position 4:
Position 3: E
Position 2:
Position 1:
2. "Only one box is kept between box E and box B." Since E is at Position 3, B can be at Position 5 or Position 1.
- Case 1: B is at Position 5.
- Case 2: B is at Position 1.
3. "Box C is kept immediately above box B."
- In Case 1 (B is at Position 5), C must be immediately above B (Position 6).
- In Case 2 (B is at Position 1), C must be immediately above B (Position 2).
Let's represent the configurations:
Case 1:
6: C
5: B
4:
3: E
2:
1:
Case 2:
6:
5:
4:
3: E
2: C
1: B
4. "Box D is kept above box F but below box A." This means the relative order is A ... D ... F.
- In Case 1, we have three empty slots: 4, 2, and 1. Placing A, D, F in these slots gives: A at 4, D at 2, and F at 1. This is a complete arrangement: C (6), B (5), A (4), E (3), D (2), F (1). In this case, 4 boxes (C, B, A, E) are above D.
- In Case 2, we have three empty slots: 6, 5, and 4. Placing A, D, F in these slots gives: A at 6, D at 5, and F at 4. This is a complete arrangement: A (6), D (5), F (4), E (3), C (2), B (1). In this case, 1 box (A) is above D.
Since Statement I gives two different possible positions for D, we cannot uniquely determine how many boxes are kept above D. Thus, Statement I alone is not sufficient.
Analyzing Statement II:
1. "Box C is kept four boxes above box F." This means there are three boxes between C and F (i.e., C is at position x and F is at position x - 4). The possible positions for (C, F) are:
- Case A: C at 6, F at 2
- Case B: C at 5, F at 1
2. "Box C and box A are kept adjacent to each other."
- In Case A (C at 6), A must be at 5.
- In Case B (C at 5), A can be at 6 or 4.
3. "More than two boxes are kept between box A and box E."
- Let's test Case A (C at 6, A at 5, F at 2):
We need more than 2 boxes (i.e., at least 3 boxes) between A (5) and E. The positions between 5 and E must be 4, 3 (if E is at 1) or similar. Let's see: if E is at 1, there are three boxes (4, 3, 2) between A (5) and E (1). Since F is already at 2, E must be at 1. So, E is at 1.
Let's check the slots for Case A: 6 (C), 5 (A), 4 (empty), 3 (empty), 2 (F), 1 (E). The remaining boxes to place are B and D in slots 4 and 3. The next clue says "Box B is kept below box D." So D must be at 4 and B must be at 3. This gives the unique stack: C (6), A (5), D (4), B (3), F (2), E (1). Let's verify the condition: "More than two boxes are kept between box A and box E": A is at 5, E is at 1. The boxes between them are at positions 4, 3, and 2 (D, B, and F). There are exactly 3 boxes, which is "more than two". All conditions are satisfied. Here, the boxes above D (4) are A and C (2 boxes).
- Let's test Case B (C at 5, F at 1):
Subcase B1: A is at 6.
We need more than 2 boxes between A (6) and E. This means E can only be at 2 or 1. But F is at 1, so E must be at 2. The positions between A (6) and E (2) are 5, 4, 3 (three positions), which satisfies the condition. The slots are: 6 (A), 5 (C), 4 (empty), 3 (empty), 2 (E), 1 (F). The remaining boxes B and D must go to 4 and 3. Since B is below D, D is at 4 and B is at 3. This gives: A (6), C (5), D (4), B (3), E (2), F (1). However, let's re-verify the conditions. This also gives a valid arrangement where D is at 4 (2 boxes above D).
Subcase B2: A is at 4.
We need more than 2 boxes between A (4) and E. The only way to have at least 3 boxes between 4 and E is if E is at a position separated by at least 3 slots, which is impossible in a 6-box stack when A is at 4.
Wait, let's check if there is a unique answer for the number of boxes above D in all valid configurations under Statement II:
- In Case A: Stack is C (6), A (5), D (4), B (3), F (2), E (1). The number of boxes above D is 2 (C and A).
- In Case B1: Stack is A (6), C (5), D (4), B (3), E (2), F (1). The number of boxes above D is 2 (A and C).
In both valid cases, box D is positioned at index 4 (from the bottom), meaning there are exactly 2 boxes kept above box D (positions 5 and 6). Therefore, Statement II alone provides a unique and sufficient answer to the question.
Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.
Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.
Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.
Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.
Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.
Copyright © 2026 Combe Labs Private Limited. All Rights Reserved.