There are two containers X and Y. X contains 100 ml of milk and Y contains 100 ml of water. 20 ml of milk from X is transferred to Y. After mixing well, 20 ml of the mixture in Y is transferred back to X. If m denotes the proportion of milk in X and n denotes the proportion of water in Y, then which one of the following is correct?
Correct Answer :
m = n
Solution :
The correct option is m = n.
Let us understand this result step-by-step by tracking the volumes of milk and water in both containers throughout the process.
Step 1: Initial State
Container X contains 100 ml of milk and 0 ml of water (Total volume = 100 ml).
Container Y contains 0 ml of milk and 100 ml of water (Total volume = 100 ml).
Step 2: First Transfer
20 ml of milk is transferred from X to Y.
After this transfer:
In Container X: Milk remaining = 100 - 20 = 80 ml. Water = 0 ml. (Total volume = 80 ml).
In Container Y: Water = 100 ml, Milk added = 20 ml. (Total volume = 120 ml).
The concentration of milk in Y is:
The concentration of water in Y is:
Step 3: Second Transfer (Back to X)
After mixing Y thoroughly, 20 ml of this mixture is transferred back to X.
Since the mixture is homogeneous, the 20 ml transferred contains milk and water in the ratio of their concentrations in Y:
Milk in the transferred 20 ml =
ml.
Water in the transferred 20 ml =
ml.
Step 4: Final State Calculation
Let us calculate the quantities in each container after the second transfer:
In Container X:
Final volume of X is 80 ml + 20 ml = 100 ml.
Final Milk in X = 80 +
ml.
The proportion of milk in X (denoted by m) is:
In Container Y:
Final volume of Y is 120 ml - 20 ml = 100 ml.
Final Water in Y = 100 -
ml.
The proportion of water in Y (denoted by n) is:
Comparing the values, we find that:
Therefore, the relationship m = n always holds true, regardless of the intermediate concentrations, because the total volume in both containers remains identical to the starting volumes (100 ml each), ensuring that any milk displaced from X must be replaced by an equal volume of water from Y.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Mindyard. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Mindyard. All Rights Reserved.