To check the principle of multiple proportions, a series of pure binary compounds (PmQn) were analyzed and their composition is tabulated below. The correct option(s) is (are)
| Compound | Weight % of P | Weight % of Q |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 50 | 50 |
| 2 | 44.4 | 55.6 |
| 3 | 40 | 60 |
Correct Answer :
If empirical formula of compound 3 is P3Q2 and atomic weight of element P is 20, then the atomic weight of Q is 45.
If empirical formula of compound 2 is PQ, then the empirical formula of the compound 1 is P5Q4.
Solution :
The correct options are: "If empirical formula of compound 3 is P3Q2 and atomic weight of element P is 20, then the atomic weight of Q is 45" and "If empirical formula of compound 2 is PQ, then the empirical formula of compound 1 is P5Q4."
First, let us extract the key data from the table. The weight percentages are:
Compound 1: P = 50%, Q = 50%
Compound 2: P = 44.4%, Q = 55.6%
Compound 3: P = 40%, Q = 60%
From these percentages, we can calculate the weight ratio of P to Q in each compound:
Compound 1: P : Q = 50 : 50 = 1 : 1
Compound 2: P : Q = 44.4 : 55.6 = 4 : 5 (dividing both by 11.1)
Compound 3: P : Q = 40 : 60 = 2 : 3
Now let us verify each of the two correct options step by step.
─────────────────────────────────
Option B: Empirical formula of compound 3 is P3Q2, atomic weight of P = 20 → find atomic weight of Q.
If the empirical formula is P3Q2, then in one formula unit there are 3 atoms of P and 2 atoms of Q. The mass contributed by each element is:
Mass of P portion = 3 × (atomic weight of P) = 3 × 20 = 60
Mass of Q portion = 2 × (atomic weight of Q) = 2 × MQ
The weight ratio of P to Q in compound 3 must equal 2 : 3 (from the table data above).
So we set up the equation:
Cross-multiplying:
The atomic weight of Q = 45. ✓ This option is correct.
─────────────────────────────────
Option C: Empirical formula of compound 2 is PQ → find empirical formula of compound 1.
If compound 2 has the empirical formula PQ, then the mole ratio of P : Q = 1 : 1, and the weight ratio of P : Q must also equal the ratio of their atomic weights:
From compound 2: weight ratio P : Q = 44.4 : 55.6 = 4 : 5, so:
Let MP = 4k and MQ = 5k for some constant k.
Now use compound 1 where weight ratio P : Q = 50 : 50 = 1 : 1.
If compound 1 has empirical formula PmQn, the weight ratio is:
Substituting MP = 4k and MQ = 5k:
So the simplest whole-number ratio is m : n = 5 : 4, giving the empirical formula P5Q4. ✓
This option is correct.
─────────────────────────────────
Why are Options A and D incorrect?
Option A says: If compound 3 is P3Q4, find compound 2. If compound 3 is P3Q4, then weight ratio P : Q = (3MP) : (4MQ) = 2 : 3, which gives MP/MQ = 8/9. For compound 2 with weight ratio 4 : 5: moles ratio = (4/MP) : (5/MQ) = (4 × 9) : (5 × 8) = 36 : 40 = 9 : 10. The empirical formula would be P9Q10, not P3Q5. So Option A is incorrect.
Option D says: Atomic weights of P = 70, Q = 35, find formula of compound 1. Weight ratio in compound 1 = P : Q = 1 : 1. Moles of P = 50/70 = 5/7, moles of Q = 50/35 = 10/7. Ratio of moles P : Q = (5/7) : (10/7) = 1 : 2. So the empirical formula is PQ2, not P2Q. So Option D is incorrect.
─────────────────────────────────
Summary: The two correct options are B (atomic weight of Q = 45) and C (empirical formula of compound 1 is P5Q4), both of which are verified by correctly applying the weight-to-mole ratio logic and the principle of multiple proportions.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Mindyard. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Mindyard. All Rights Reserved.