Question Details

Two nucleon reactions are given below:

He23 → He24 + 20 MeV

He24 → He25 − 0.9 MeV

Find stability order of He23, He24, He25.

Options

A

He25 < He24 < He23

B

He23 < He25 < He24

C

He24 < He23 < He25

D

He25 < He23 < He24

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option B

He23 < He25 < He24

He23 < He25 < He24

Solution :

To determine the stability order of the helium isotopes (He23, He24, and He25), we need to analyze their binding energy per nucleon. The stability of a nucleus is directly proportional to its binding energy per nucleon (Ebn).

Let B(He2A) represent the total binding energy of the isotope with mass number A.

1. First Reaction:
He23He24+20 MeV
This reaction represents the addition of a neutron to He23 to form He24, releasing 20 MeV of energy. Therefore, the binding energy of He24 is greater than that of He23 by 20 MeV:
B(He24)=B(He23)+20 MeV

2. Second Reaction:
He24He25-0.9 MeV
This reaction indicates that the addition of a neutron to He24 to form He25 requires an input of 0.9 MeV (or absorbs energy). Thus, the binding energy of He25 is less than that of He24 by 0.9 MeV:
B(He25)=B(He24)-0.9 MeV=B(He23)+19.1 MeV

3. Calculating Binding Energy per Nucleon:
The binding energy of Helium-3 (He23) is approximately 7.7 MeV. Let us use this value to find the binding energy per nucleon (Ebn=BA) for each isotope:
• For He23 (nucleons A=3):
Ebn(He23)=7.732.57 MeV/nucleon
• For He24 (nucleons A=4):
Ebn(He24)=7.7+204=27.746.93 MeV/nucleon
• For He25 (nucleons A=5):
Ebn(He25)=27.7-0.95=26.85=5.36 MeV/nucleon

Comparing these values, we get:
2.57 MeV/nucleon<5.36 MeV/nucleon<6.93 MeV/nucleon

Therefore, the stability order is:
He23<He25<He24

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemistry, mathematics, physics
  • Proctored

  • JEE
  • intermediate
  • 3 hours
  • chemical engineering, mathematics, physics

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...