Which of the following statements are logically equivalent?
A) Some animals are birds.
B) Some animals are not non-birds.
C) Some non-birds are not non-animals.
D) Some birds are animals.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Correct Answer :
A, B and D Only
Solution :
The correct option is A, B and D Only.
Let us analyze each statement to determine their logical equivalence by translating them into standard logical forms using set theory or formal representation:
Let represent the set of animals and represent the set of birds.
Statement A: "Some animals are birds."
This is a standard existential statement (particular affirmative, I-proposition). In set notation, it means there is at least one member in the intersection of animals and birds:
Statement B: "Some animals are not non-birds."
According to the rule of double negation, a "not non-bird" is simply a "bird". Thus, saying "Some animals are not non-birds" is logically equivalent to saying "Some animals are birds."
In terms of sets, if an animal is not in the complement of (denoted as ), it must be in :
Statement C: "Some non-birds are not non-animals."
Applying the double negation rule, a "not non-animal" is an "animal". Therefore, this statement translates to: "Some non-birds are animals" (or "Some animals are not birds").
In set notation, this means:
This statement asserts the existence of an animal that is not a bird, which is not logically equivalent to Statement A (which asserts the existence of an animal that is a bird).
Statement D: "Some birds are animals."
By the rule of conversion for I-propositions, "Some S is P" is logically equivalent to "Some P is S." Hence, "Some animals are birds" is logically equivalent to "Some birds are animals."
In set notation, since the intersection of two sets is commutative:
Comparing these formulations, we find that Statements A, B, and D all represent the same logical relation: the intersection of the set of animals and the set of birds is not empty (). Therefore, statements A, B, and D are logically equivalent.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Mindyard. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Mindyard. All Rights Reserved.