Question Details

XVII. Surrogacy is defined by law as “a practice whereby one woman bears and gives birth to a child for an intending couple” and intends to hand over the child to them after the birth, as per the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 (the “SRA”). The SRA restricts altruistic surrogacy to legally wedded infertile Indian couples. The couple is deemed eligible for surrogacy only if they have been married for five years. The SRA sets an age limitation for the couple. A husband must be between 26 and 55 years of age and a wife between 23 and 50 years. Further, Indian couples with biological or adopted children are prohibited from undertaking surrogacy, save for some exceptions such as mentally or physically challenged children, or those suffering from a life-threatening disorder or fatal illness. The SRA provides that the surrogate mother has to be a close relative of the couple (such as a sibling of one of the members of the couple), a married woman with a child of her own, aged between 25 and 35 years, who has been a surrogate only once in her life. Even within this category of people, commercial surrogacy is banned in India and that includes the “commercialisation of surrogacy services or procedures or its component services or component procedures”. The surrogate woman cannot be given payments, rewards, benefits or fees, “except the medical expenses and such other prescribed expenses incurred on the surrogate mother and the insurance coverage for the surrogate mother”.


A legal commentator points out some criticisms of the law. “Permitting limited conditional surrogacy to married Indian couples and disqualifying other persons on basis of nationality, marital status, sexual orientation or age does not pass the test of equality,” he writes. He adds that reproductive autonomy, inclusive of the right to procreation and parenthood is protected under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty. The intending parents typically sign a contract with the surrogate. The Indian Contract Act, 1872 (the “ICA”) provides that a valid contract has to be in writing, and signed in the presence of two witnesses. The ICA also provides that a contract that is prohibited by any other law will not be valid under the ICA.


Queen runs a surrogacy clinic. She employs 54 women, aged between 25 and 35 years. They are all married women with one or more children. Most of them belong to economically disadvantaged backgrounds. They choose to be surrogates because it gives them a reliable source of income. Kishore and Noor are intending parents. They have been married 5 years, are both aged 35, and do not have children. Kishore has been certified as infertile. So, they decide to approach Queen’s clinic. They sign a contract with the surrogate. The contract is in writing and is signed in the presence of two witnesses. As per the contract, Kishore and Noor are required to remunerate the surrogate with 2 lakh per child born as a result of surrogacy, and take care of her medical needs, including providing her with medical insurance. A healthy baby girl is born as a result of surrogacy. Kishore and Noor are overjoyed. They take care of the surrogate’s medical expenses. However, they do not pay the surrogate the 2 lakh. The surrogate, supported by Queen, now wants to take Kishore and Noor to court, to demand that they make the payment. Will she succeed?

Options

A

Yes, because Kishore and Noor are bound by the contract under the ICA.

B

Yes, because the intending parents and the surrogate meet the eligibility requirements under the SRA.

C

No, because the surrogate meets the eligibility requirements under the SRA.

D

No, because SRA allows only altruistic surrogacy, so the contract is not valid under the ICA.

Show Answer
Correct Answer
D No, because SRA allows only altruistic surrogacy, so the contract is not valid under the ICA.

Solution :

Correct Answer: No, because SRA allows only altruistic surrogacy, so the contract is not valid under the ICA.


Step-by-Step Explanation:


1. Understanding the Legal Provisions (Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021):
According to the passage, the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 (SRA) strictly permits only altruistic surrogacy and bans commercial surrogacy in India. Commercial surrogacy includes any commercialisation of surrogacy services, payments, rewards, benefits, or fees paid to the surrogate woman beyond medical expenses and prescribed insurance coverage.


2. Application to the Contractual Terms (Indian Contract Act, 1872):
In this scenario, the contract between Kishore, Noor, and the surrogate included a stipulation to remunerate the surrogate with ₹2 lakh per child born. Because this payment goes beyond medical expenses and insurance, it amounts to commercial surrogacy, which is prohibited under the SRA.


3. Validity of the Contract:
The passage explicitly states that under the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (ICA), any contract that is prohibited by any other law will not be valid. Since the agreement for monetary remuneration (commercial surrogacy) is barred by the SRA, the contract itself is illegal and invalid under the ICA.


Conclusion:
Because the contract violates the SRA's ban on commercial surrogacy, it is unenforceable and invalid under the ICA. Therefore, the surrogate will not succeed in court in demanding the ₹2 lakh payment.

Transparent Access on Mindyard

Built for Learners & Educators Alike

Completely free for students. Educators & coaching institutes get 2 months free Pro trial to create tests.

FREE FOR STUDENTS

Practice & Learn Free for Students

Access unlimited practice questions, detailed step-by-step solutions, and exam study materials — completely free for students.

  • Unlimited mock tests & question bank practice
  • Full access to curated study library & formula notes
  • 100% free for students • No credit card required
2 MONTHS FREE TRIAL

Educators & Coaching Institutes

Create and conduct professional online assessments with AI question generation, tab proctoring, and comprehensive batch management.

  • AI question uploader & rapid test generator
  • Anti-cheating tab proctoring & performance reports
  • Full Pro access free for 60 days • No upfront commitment
Discover more resources

You may also like

Mock Tests

View All
  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Practice the complete CLAT 2015 UG Question Paper to improve your preparation for the Common Law Admission Test. This previous year paper covers the key sections of CLAT UG, including English, General Knowledge & Current Affairs, Elementary Mathematics, Legal Aptitude, and Logical Reasoning. Solve CLAT 2015 UG questions to understand the previous year exam pattern, practice important concepts, improve accuracy and speed, and prepare effectively for law entrance examinations.

  • CLAT
  • intermediate
  • 2 hours
  • current affairs, english, general knowledge, legal reasoning, logical reasoning, quant

Prepare for CLAT 2019 UG with the complete question paper and solutions. This paper covers all major sections of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) Undergraduate exam, including English Language, Current Affairs & General Knowledge, Legal Reasoning, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Techniques.Use the CLAT 2019 UG question paper to practice exam-level questions, understand the question pattern, improve time management, and strengthen your preparation for law entrance examinations.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...
Ask your own doubt or choose a quick prompt: