Question Details

Directions: Read the following passage carefully and answer the question that follows.

Nearly four decades ago, a coalition of rural villagers in a secluded region of the Andes halted a corporate logging operation slated to clear a nearby forest. This confrontation sparked the regional conservation movement, symbolizing a broader wave of ecological conflicts throughout the late 20th century. These disputes spanned disputes over woodlands, marine fisheries, and communal grazing lands, as well as protests against massive hydroelectric projects and unchecked mining operations. In each instance, the expansion of urban markets and industrial growth restricted rural populations from utilizing the natural resources vital for their daily sustenance.

While environmentalism in wealthier nations often centered on preserving wild areas and safeguarding endangered fauna, the movement in this developing region was driven by basic human survival. It emerged as an advocacy system of the marginalized, fusing demands for social equity with ecological sustainability. Proponents contended that the prevailing systems of resource exploitation disenfranchised local populations while degrading the natural habitats they depended on.

Decades ago, when state-controlled economic planning predominated, critics initially dismissed these local conservation efforts as foreign-backed interference. Over time, however, the persistence of these demonstrations compelled the administration to implement regulatory reforms. Environmental protection agencies were created, and new legislation was enacted to limit pollution and conserve primary forests. Yet, when economic liberalization policies were introduced in the 1990s, the reduction of state oversight led to even more aggressive exploitation of natural habitats by private enterprises, surpassing the ecological damage caused under the previous state-run system.

Which of the following claims contradicts the information given in the passage?

Options

A

Every statement listed is consistent with the passage.

B

The economic reforms of the 1990s increased official supervision and made pollution safeguards more rigorous.

C

The villagers’ opposition to logging became an important beginning for the region’s broader conservation campaign.

D

Environmental disputes in the late twentieth century concerned varied resources as well as major development schemes.

E

Continued protests by local communities eventually led to the establishment of environmental bodies and protective laws.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option B

The economic reforms of the 1990s increased official supervision and made pollution safeguards more rigorous.

Solution :

The correct option is: "The economic reforms of the 1990s increased official supervision and made pollution safeguards more rigorous."

Step-by-Step Explanation:

Step 1: Understand the Goal
The task is to find the claim among the options that directly contradicts (states the opposite of) the information presented in the reading passage.

Step 2: Analyze the Relevant Portion of the Passage
In the third paragraph, the passage addresses the economic policies of the 1990s:
"Yet, when economic liberalization policies were introduced in the 1990s, the reduction of state oversight led to even more aggressive exploitation of natural habitats by private enterprises..."

Step 3: Evaluate the Option
The selected option claims that the 1990s economic reforms "increased official supervision and made pollution safeguards more rigorous."
Since the passage explicitly affirms that state oversight was reduced (decreased) rather than increased, this claim directly contradicts the facts provided in the text.

Step 4: Confirm Consistency of Remaining Options
Villagers' confrontation starting the movement: Paragraph 1 mentions this confrontation "sparked the regional conservation movement."
Disputes spanning varied resources: Paragraph 1 notes disputes over "woodlands, marine fisheries, and communal grazing lands, as well as protests against massive hydroelectric projects."
Protests leading to environmental bodies and laws: Paragraph 3 notes "demonstrations compelled the administration to implement regulatory reforms. Environmental protection agencies were created..."

Thus, the claim regarding the 1990s economic reforms increasing official supervision is the only statement that directly contradicts the passage.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...