Question Details

On the day of writing this, India had reported 116 deaths from COVID-19. In contrast, the US, with around one-fourth the population of India, reported 1,897 deaths, or 16 times the daily deaths as India. The UK, which has one-twentieth the population of India, reported 592 deaths, or 5 times the daily deaths as India. On other metrics too-new cases, active cases-the Indian curve has flattened. If and when the UK and the US achieve what we have, there will be major celebrations. Such low death rates would be seen as a victory of the government, citizens and science over the dreaded coronavirus. However, because we are India, we don’t get as much credit. We are considered poor, third-world and untrustworthy, incapable of achieving something like this on our own. Instead of learning from India’s experience, the first instinct is to doubt Indian data. We aren’t counting the cases right, we aren’t doing enough tests, we don’t classify the deaths properly-the list of doubts goes on and on. This, even as the tests have only increased, positivity rate has dropped and almost all Indian hospitals are seeing a drop in COVID-19 admissions and fatalities. To think that the Deep Indian State is capable of fudging data at the level of every district and every state, and sustaining this façade for months is giving it way too much credit. Conspiracies require enormous co-ordination and effort and it isn’t quite how things work in India. Given that you can check corona data at every ward level, it is also impossible to fudge data, not to mention create a downwards curve that is moving in the same direction in virtually every corner of India. In terms of testing, while a case might be made for a lot of Indians not getting tested, it is also true that random testing has increased in the last few months. Domestic flyers into Maharashtra from many states for instance, have to get a COVID-19 test done irrespective of symptoms. If there was rampant corona, we would see a spike in cases from just these flyers. It may be hard for people to accept this reality but almost all evidence points to the fact India has flattened the corona curve, while the US, UK and most of Europe still haven’t. What is even more remarkable about India’s achievement is that it has managed to do this without draconian lockdowns (apart from the two months in April-May 2020). In fact, cases have dropped even as India opened up more.


Which of the following strengthens the author’s argument that India has tackled the COVID-19 pandemic better than most advanced nations?

Options

A

India’s positivity rate of COVID-19 cases and admissions in Indian hospitals are reduced.

B

India’s counting of the number of COVID-19 cases is incorrect.

C

India’s testing facilities for COVID-19 cases are inadequate.

D

India’s classification of COVID-19 cases is inaccurate.

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option A

India’s positivity rate of COVID-19 cases and admissions in Indian hospitals are reduced.

Solution :

The correct answer is: India’s positivity rate of COVID-19 cases and admissions in Indian hospitals are reduced.


Step-by-Step Explanation:


1. Understand the Goal:
The question asks us to identify the statement that strengthens the author's argument that India has tackled the COVID-19 pandemic better than most advanced nations (like the US and UK).


2. Analyze the Passage:
The author argues that India has successfully flattened the COVID-19 curve compared to the US and UK, pointing out key evidence directly from the ground:
- Daily deaths and active cases in India are significantly lower.
- Testing has increased while the positivity rate has dropped.
- Almost all Indian hospitals are experiencing a clear drop in COVID-19 admissions and fatalities.
The author counters skeptics by asserting that actual data and hospital trends support this success, making it real rather than fudged data.


3. Evaluate the Options:


Option 1: "India’s positivity rate of COVID-19 cases and admissions in Indian hospitals are reduced."
This statement directly supports and confirms the concrete empirical evidence cited by the author. A lower positivity rate coupled with fewer hospital admissions serves as strong proof that the spread of the virus has actually slowed down and that India has handled the pandemic effectively. Therefore, this option strengthens the author's argument.


Option 2: "India’s counting of the number of COVID-19 cases is incorrect."
This statement weakens or raises doubts about the author's claim by suggesting that the low numbers are due to miscounting rather than actual success.


Option 3: "India’s testing facilities for COVID-19 cases are inadequate."
This statement also weakens the argument by implying that low case numbers might simply be a result of insufficient testing.


Option 4: "India’s classification of COVID-19 cases is inaccurate."
This statement undermines the credibility of the data, thereby weakening the author's argument.


Conclusion:
Only the reduction in positivity rates and hospital admissions provides factual support reinforcing the author's conclusion that India has successfully controlled the pandemic.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...