Choose the correct option in the light of the following statement:
“The fact that I am a black working-class man will determine my worldview just as much, and perhaps far more than I consciously learn in the domain of ideas.”
(A) Man is capable of making free choices in the sphere of intellection and morality.
(B) The unconscious determines human thought and behaviour
(C) Man is condemned to be free
(D) We bear a form of “otherness” within ourselves
(E) We can no longer talk unequivocally of a writer’s intention.
Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
Correct Answer :
(B), (D) and (E) Only
Solution :
The correct answer is (B), (D) and (E) Only.
Step-by-Step Explanation:
The statement, “The fact that I am a black working-class man will determine my worldview just as much, and perhaps far more than I consciously learn in the domain of ideas,” highlights the role of socio-historical positioning (race, class, and gender) and structural forces in shaping human consciousness, subjectivity, and identity, rather than conscious intellect or absolute free will. Let us analyze each of the given statements in the context of this quote:
1. Analysis of Statement (B):
The quote emphasizes that one's worldview is determined by deep-seated social positionings that operate below or outside of conscious learning ("domain of ideas"). This aligns with theories of the psychoanalytic and structural unconscious, which posit that human thought and behavior are profoundly shaped by factors outside of conscious awareness. Therefore, statement (B) is supported by the quote.
2. Analysis of Statement (D):
The quote deals with how specific marginalized identities (being a "black working-class man") construct one's perspective. In modern critical theory and psychoanalysis, this means our identity is not a unified, fully transparent self, but is constructed through relationships with the "Other" and contains internal splits or "otherness" (unconscious social and cultural conditioning). Thus, statement (D) is relevant and correct.
3. Analysis of Statement (E):
If a writer's worldview is determined primarily by structural, unconscious, and socio-economic factors (like class and race) rather than pure conscious agency, we can no longer view a text as simply the product of a writer's clear, conscious intent. This post-structuralist understanding means we cannot talk unequivocally of a writer's conscious intention as the absolute source of meaning, validating statement (E).
Why Statements (A) and (C) are incorrect:
Statements (A) and (C) represent classical humanist and existentialist viewpoints (such as Sartre's "man is condemned to be free") that champion absolute individual agency and conscious moral choice. The given quote directly challenges this by asserting that structural positions (race, class) determine our worldview far more than conscious intellectual choices.
Thus, only statements (B), (D), and (E) are appropriate in the light of the given statement.
Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.
Create, conduct, and manage professional online assessments with Mindyard. Perfect for teachers and institutes.
Copyright © 2026 Mindyard. All Rights Reserved.