Question Details

A heat engine extracts heat (QH ) from a thermal reservoir at a temperature of 1000 K and rejects heat (QL ) to a thermal reservoir at a temperature of 100 K, while producing work (W). Which one of the combinations of [QH , QL and W] given is allowed?

Options

A

QH = 2000 J, QL = 500 J, W = 1000 J

B

QH = 2000 J, QL = 750 J, W = 1250 J

C

QH = 6000 J, QL = 500 J, W = 5500 J

D

QH = 6000 J, QL = 600 J, W = 5500 J

Show Answer

Correct Answer :

Option B

QH = 2000 J, QL = 750 J, W = 1250 J

Solution :

The correct option is:
QH = 2000 J, QL = 750 J, W = 1250 J

Analysis of the Engine Diagram and Thermodynamic Principles:
Based on the provided diagram, the heat engine operates under the following conditions:
1. It extracts heat QH from a source at temperature T1=1000K.
2. It rejects heat QL (indicated as Q2 in the image calculations) to a sink at temperature T2=100K.
3. It performs work output W.

For any cyclic process to be possible, it must satisfy two fundamental laws of thermodynamics:

1. First Law of Thermodynamics (Conservation of Energy):
The energy entering the engine must equal the total energy leaving it.

QH=W+QL

2. Second Law of Thermodynamics (Clausius Inequality):
As explicitly shown in the accompanying image, the cyclic integral of heat transfer divided by temperature must be less than or equal to zero for a feasible cycle:

dQT0
For this two-reservoir system, the inequality becomes:

QHT1-QLT20

Evaluating the Given Options:

Option A: QH = 2000 J, QL = 500 J, W = 1000 J
• First Law check: W+QL=1000+500=1500J.
Since 1500J2000J, this option violates the First Law of Thermodynamics.

Option B (Correct): QH = 2000 J, QL = 750 J, W = 1250 J
• First Law check: W+QL=1250+750=2000J. This satisfies the First Law.
• Second Law check:

dQT=20001000-750100=2-7.5=-5.5J/K
Since -5.5<0, the Clausius inequality is satisfied, making this a physically possible, irreversible thermodynamic cycle.

Option C: QH = 6000 J, QL = 500 J, W = 5500 J
• First Law check: W+QL=5500+500=6000J. This satisfies the First Law.
• Second Law check:

dQT=60001000-500100=6-5=+1J/K
Since +1>0, this cycle violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics (it exceeds the maximum possible Carnot efficiency between these temperatures).

Option D: QH = 6000 J, QL = 600 J, W = 5500 J
• First Law check: W+QL=5500+600=6100J.
Since 6100J6000J, this option violates the First Law of Thermodynamics.

Unlock Our Free Library

Access expert-curated educational resources and study materials—completely free.

Ask AI Tutor
5 left
Q1 View Question & Options
AI Tutor is solving this question...
Reading question context & options...